Originally Posted by Freeloader
It has nothing to do with the games, it would be more like if a Red Dead Redemption comic came out and we voted John Marston as a better comic character than Batman.
Number of video games where Batman is a playable character - 39 excluding mobile phone games.
Number of video games where John Marston is a playable character - 1.
He may have been taken from comic books but the two Arkham games alone would make him a classic video game character. Those two games are inspired by the comics, but they are completely original stories in their own right.