Vickie at the time was having an angle with Edge and the Undertaker. She was known for her annoying catchphrases like "EXCUSE MEEE!", up to now. Her current "feminist" gimmick is not bad either, in fact, she has improved. Even though I think she needs to retire by now, she has already solidified as one of the all-time women in pro wrestling.
As for Karen, I only watched her stint in Youtube. All I can say is that she was getting WAY too much TV time. What takes the cake is her real-life-turned-storytelling angle with Kurt and JJ. Before that, she was trash and made Kurt even look bad.
I have no idea about Karen in 2008 I can talk about Jarrett. I think the two are very good.
Vickie Guerrero is a heat machine, she doesn't need to talk to be booed. She just need to be in the arena, every heel wish they were heel like that and thanks to her, Dolph Ziggler is on a totally new level now.
Karen Jarrett on the other side is less effective I think because she need to change her voice and I think that if she isn't a awesome manager like Vickie and booed very hard, she is still a big bitch. She try to ruin Kurt Angle's life and let's not talk about the knockouts division. You could also had that she is a MILF
But in the end, I think I will go for Vickie. I prefer Karen but overall, Vickie is better from my point of view
Not only does Karen look good but she was more interesting than Vickie. Vickie hasn't been interesting since 09/010. I actually enjoyed what Karen was doing with Madison Rayne as her Corporate Champion considering the KO Division hasn't had a legit Commissioner since Jim Cornette/Traci Brooks.
Karen Angle/Jarrett is a poor women's Vickie Guerrero. She's no where close to Vickie in terms of being a heat magnet, and Vickie has grown on me now, Karen hasn't.
Karen, because I feel that Vickie relies too much on her annoying voice and the commentators/wrestlers burying her looks. It's easy to hate someone if they're annoying and "ugly" (though not saying Vickie really is). And I found Karen more interesting. Vickie definitely engenders the go-away heat.
I hope by female GOAT you mean the animal, because I would be cautious about using Greatest of all time with someone like Karen. She wouldn't be in the top 100, and even then she might be further.
Karen Angle sexy as fuck but Vickie is still a big role in the E so I give it to Vickie!
Status
Not open for further replies.
You have insufficient privileges to reply here.
Related Threads
?
?
?
?
?
Wrestling Forum
23.4M posts
266.5K members
Since 2002
A forum community dedicated to all Wrestling enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about WWE, AEW, Ring of Honor, Impact and all forms of professional and amateur wrestling.