He can't touch CAM in terms of rookie RAPE ability.
yeah all those failed wins really meant a lot, almost as much as they mean this year. Cam doesn't compare to Luck and there is a reason Luck would have been drafted ahead of Cam in the 2011 draft as well, even you wanted Luck.
I'm pretty sure the consensus top 5 right now is in any order: Rodgers, Brady, Brees, Peyton, Eli.
Btw, I'm not too sure about Luck making a jump into top 5 next year. Let's not get ahead of ourselves. He's not even the best QB from his draft class, at least not the consensus one.
He plays like a pro and has the posture of one. Anything could happen next year, hell Eli has already played like shit this season so there's no reason to think he could easily fall out of his spot if he doesn't do well in the playoffs again.
Originally Posted by The MAGIC of ChristmasView Post
My list is basically the same as Notorious' except I think he's on par with Eli. There are the elite and then subelite guys like Eli/Ben who step up when their teams need it most and play at an elite level.
If you're saying that Ben is the 5th best QB in the league then why are we even arguing about this...
Maple Leafs - Raptors - Steelers - Blue Jays - Florida State