Who would you give the Offensive ROY to? Luck, RG3, and Wilson all deserve it. Guys like Martin and Richardson would at least be in the conversation any other year.
Standing by my point. It's hard to argue the worth of all 3 when they've been just as essential as the next in regards to helping their team come along.
Luck won't win as his stats aren't good enough for him to win it.
RGIII will win due to his far bigger role and better statistics as well.
Wilson has been good, even great for his rookie year, but he won't win it.
out of the three Luck has easily been the most valuable, as Kirk Cousins proved, RGIII isn't the only QB on the Skins that can win and play well. Their team as a whole is a lot better than most people give them credit for. Wilson is a great system right now with a great team. And LUCK is well LUCK. what a guy.
Not surprised. I've credited RAMS as the most inconsistent team in the league. One week they're boss. Next week they're trash. But, congrats to them. It's like when Oakland went 6-0 in their division despite only having a record of 8-8. Only 2 wins were against non-division teams :lol
Um, I can quite easily say that RGIII/Luck's impact has been greater than Wilson's. Yes he has helped in a tremendous way, but he easily had the best team coming in. An elite defense, the best secondary in the league(not that we knew this at the time, but we all knew they were one of the best), an elite runningback, and a good offensive line. I'd say he has the worst receiving corps out of three though, so he does get bonus points for that.
That's my way of thinking too. The accomplishment of turning around the worst team in the league last year to not only be better, but have a winning record that will lead them into the post-season, is magnificent. He could be the new Peyton. BIG shoes to fill, but look what he's done already.
Luck has 7 4th quarter comebacks this year. He is literally carrying the team on his back, RGII is not as the Redskins are a good team whether people want to admit it or not, its not just RGIII. Id take Luck every day of the week.
its not only magnificent, its never been done before. never has a QB taken first overall had a winning record, let alone making the playoffs. LUCK is the best out of three, and of course I have some homer bias to that, but there is a reason he was taken first overall and built up as the beast he is. That being said he wont win the ROY due it being award that goes to the player with basically the best statistics, its more like the Offensive Player of the Year award where they judge mostly by the stats you put up and Lucks stats werenèt that impressive this year.
Award is irrelevant when trying to make the comparison or simply putting over how much of a success Luck is for the franchise. Sure, winning it would assist the notion, but it's obvious to anyone who sees the Colts play. He's legit.
I wouldn't call Luck out on that. I've seen Matt Ryan do the same this year in a few games. Vs Oakland being the main one. He threw 6 INTs yet still managed to come back to win. I know Oakland isn't very good, but they brought that game. Sometimes the QBs make mistakes, but being good enough to fix those mistakes is almost as impressive as not making any to begin with.
A forum community dedicated to all Wrestling enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about WWE, AEW, Ring of Honor, Impact and all forms of professional and amateur wrestling.