College Athletes, Are They Employees? - Wrestling Forum : WWE, TNA, Debate League, Wrestling Videos, Women of Wrestling Forums
Reply

Old 03-26-2014, 08:38 PM   #1 (permalink)
Little Poppa Pump
 
Join Date: Jun 2012
Location: Mizzou Tiger Country
Posts: 2,420
TomahawkJock 1001 - 1500TomahawkJock 1001 - 1500TomahawkJock 1001 - 1500TomahawkJock 1001 - 1500TomahawkJock 1001 - 1500TomahawkJock 1001 - 1500TomahawkJock 1001 - 1500TomahawkJock 1001 - 1500TomahawkJock 1001 - 1500TomahawkJock 1001 - 1500
Default College Athletes, Are They Employees?

I just wanted to get people's thoughts on this. And mostly from sports fans currently in college, I'm looking at you AID

I did a research paper on it for my College English (High School senior) class and in my honest opinion, I believe they are. They practice, workout and play games for a shit ton of hours per week, and have no time to study and/or get a job. I realize scholarships pay for a lot (not EVERYTHING though like people presume) but they have no free money for recreational activities if they so wished. That, and when they are injured in their sport, they have to pay for everything THEMSELVES if the injury is severe and doesn't allow them to play again. That can put the athletes in massive debt their whole life if their careers don't pan out. And oh yeah, they only get scholarships if they are playing, not if they get injured and cannot continue.

Recently, after the Northwestern football team was deemed employees of the college by court. Things seem to be heading in the right direction in my opinion for college players to receive some sort of stipend of cash and/or health insurance for injuries.
__________________
TomahawkJock is online now   Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links
Advertisement
 

Old 03-26-2014, 08:43 PM   #2 (permalink)
Humbled
 
Join Date: May 2010
Location: The place where all are born and where all will return. A blue star.
Posts: 8,975
Hoopy Frood 11501 - 12000Hoopy Frood 11501 - 12000Hoopy Frood 11501 - 12000Hoopy Frood 11501 - 12000Hoopy Frood 11501 - 12000Hoopy Frood 11501 - 12000Hoopy Frood 11501 - 12000Hoopy Frood 11501 - 12000Hoopy Frood 11501 - 12000Hoopy Frood 11501 - 12000Hoopy Frood 11501 - 12000
Default Re: College Athletes, Are They Employees?

Fuck no, because if they are, than athletes at private high schools who are given scholarships to attend the school and play for them are, and the hours just don't match up with what's legal for those kids.
Hoopy Frood is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-26-2014, 08:53 PM   #3 (permalink)
Wheel Man for SCOTT STEINER
 
DGenerationMC's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: Washington, D.C.
Posts: 3,325
DGenerationMC 1501 - 2000DGenerationMC 1501 - 2000DGenerationMC 1501 - 2000DGenerationMC 1501 - 2000DGenerationMC 1501 - 2000DGenerationMC 1501 - 2000DGenerationMC 1501 - 2000DGenerationMC 1501 - 2000DGenerationMC 1501 - 2000DGenerationMC 1501 - 2000DGenerationMC 1501 - 2000
Default Re: College Athletes, Are They Employees?

__________________

My Favorite Wrestling Dudes


DGenerationMC is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-27-2014, 03:30 PM   #4 (permalink)
Hombre Campeón Deportes
 
Aid180's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: Athens, GA
Posts: 7,005
Aid180 7001 - 7501Aid180 7001 - 7501Aid180 7001 - 7501Aid180 7001 - 7501Aid180 7001 - 7501Aid180 7001 - 7501Aid180 7001 - 7501Aid180 7001 - 7501Aid180 7001 - 7501Aid180 7001 - 7501Aid180 7001 - 7501
Default Re: College Athletes, Are They Employees?

I'm doing a discussion on this in my Sports Contemporary issues class tomorrow so I've been putting together a few base thoughts.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Phillip J. Dick View Post
Fuck no, because if they are, than athletes at private high schools who are given scholarships to attend the school and play for them are, and the hours just don't match up with what's legal for those kids.
I'm in agreement with this. I know not every athlete is privileged and many come from poor households, but football players, here at UGA anyways, get quite a bit of compensation. First they get a full ride scholarship. No dues, no payments, no nothing. They get their living paid for, they get their food paid for, they get their school paid for. It's up to them to choose if they want to take advantage of all of that. On top of that, these athletes get several pairs of new shoes, new clothes, including workout clothes, and gifts at the end of the season, which, depending on the conference and bowl game, can range from $200-$2000 in the gift price (I'll attach the official source on bowl gifts later). To say they are playing for free is a lie. It is indeed true to say they aren't getting paid. They are getting compensated though.

You also have to look at Collegiate sports not as a job, but as an internship. What is an internship? It's a foot in the door for your career you are training for and it is training for said career. Many internships are unpaid and some work 40 hours a week. College football is like an internship. For the best players that succeed at it, it is a three-five year internship that leads to a couple million dollars or more later in his professional career. Unfortunately, not everyone makes it to the pros, but then again, not everyone at normal internships are hired after their service is done. It's unfortunate, but that is what happens.

Yes, the NCAA is scummy, but it would be the Universities that would have to pay these athletes, and not all Universities can afford to do that. In fact, many Colleges don't even generate a profit from sports. With a Union for College athletes, it wouldn't be just for Football. It would also have to include basketball, baseball, soccer, hockey, swimming, tennis, equestrian, and whatever other sports that University has. How do they decide how much they pay each athlete? Pay them same? How's that fair for Johnny Manziel over some horse-riding chick at Texas A&M? Johnny brings in much more revenue for A&M than the chick. So many logistical problems. But I still have to bring up again that not all Universities can afford to do this. Many schools actually pay for their sports via donations and student funds. Schools like UGA, Bama, Texas and others actually pay their Universities through sport. They can afford all of these athletes. Here's a reference link:
http://www.usatoday.com/sports/colle...ools/finances/

Listen, I'm not saying the NCAA is right with how they treat athletes, I just think as a whole, we need to realize that athletes are compensated in some way, and that there are poor people that go to College as well, not just football players. I feel if we just think of it as a longterm internship that leads to a big career, then it's ok. Does the NCAA generate a lot of profit? Yeah. Maybe they should use that money to help better education or get these athletes an education so they aren't left working at Micky D's if they fail in the pros.

That said, I probably have a pretty extreme opinion and I'd love to hear some other opinions for both sides.
__________________
Bears - Bulls - Braves - Blackhawks - Bulldogs


Last edited by Aid180 : 03-27-2014 at 03:32 PM.
Aid180 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-29-2014, 06:37 AM   #5 (permalink)
Acknowledged by SCOTT STEINER
 
cactus_jack22's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2010
Posts: 1,043
cactus_jack22 251 - 500cactus_jack22 251 - 500cactus_jack22 251 - 500
Default Re: College Athletes, Are They Employees?



They are getting a college degree paid for and I can tell you that's well enough for most of these athletes.
__________________
cactus_jack22 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-30-2014, 09:18 PM   #6 (permalink)
IWC's Only Ryback Mark
 
King Kai Guy's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2013
Location: In Utero
Posts: 1,016
King Kai Guy 1001 - 1500King Kai Guy 1001 - 1500King Kai Guy 1001 - 1500King Kai Guy 1001 - 1500King Kai Guy 1001 - 1500King Kai Guy 1001 - 1500King Kai Guy 1001 - 1500King Kai Guy 1001 - 1500King Kai Guy 1001 - 1500King Kai Guy 1001 - 1500
Default Re: College Athletes, Are They Employees?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Aid180 View Post
I'm doing a discussion on this in my Sports Contemporary issues class tomorrow so I've been putting together a few base thoughts.



I'm in agreement with this. I know not every athlete is privileged and many come from poor households, but football players, here at UGA anyways, get quite a bit of compensation. First they get a full ride scholarship. No dues, no payments, no nothing. They get their living paid for, they get their food paid for, they get their school paid for. It's up to them to choose if they want to take advantage of all of that. On top of that, these athletes get several pairs of new shoes, new clothes, including workout clothes, and gifts at the end of the season, which, depending on the conference and bowl game, can range from $200-$2000 in the gift price (I'll attach the official source on bowl gifts later). To say they are playing for free is a lie. It is indeed true to say they aren't getting paid. They are getting compensated though.

You also have to look at Collegiate sports not as a job, but as an internship. What is an internship? It's a foot in the door for your career you are training for and it is training for said career. Many internships are unpaid and some work 40 hours a week. College football is like an internship. For the best players that succeed at it, it is a three-five year internship that leads to a couple million dollars or more later in his professional career. Unfortunately, not everyone makes it to the pros, but then again, not everyone at normal internships are hired after their service is done. It's unfortunate, but that is what happens.

Yes, the NCAA is scummy, but it would be the Universities that would have to pay these athletes, and not all Universities can afford to do that. In fact, many Colleges don't even generate a profit from sports. With a Union for College athletes, it wouldn't be just for Football. It would also have to include basketball, baseball, soccer, hockey, swimming, tennis, equestrian, and whatever other sports that University has. How do they decide how much they pay each athlete? Pay them same? How's that fair for Johnny Manziel over some horse-riding chick at Texas A&M? Johnny brings in much more revenue for A&M than the chick. So many logistical problems. But I still have to bring up again that not all Universities can afford to do this. Many schools actually pay for their sports via donations and student funds. Schools like UGA, Bama, Texas and others actually pay their Universities through sport. They can afford all of these athletes. Here's a reference link:
http://www.usatoday.com/sports/colle...ools/finances/

Listen, I'm not saying the NCAA is right with how they treat athletes, I just think as a whole, we need to realize that athletes are compensated in some way, and that there are poor people that go to College as well, not just football players. I feel if we just think of it as a longterm internship that leads to a big career, then it's ok. Does the NCAA generate a lot of profit? Yeah. Maybe they should use that money to help better education or get these athletes an education so they aren't left working at Micky D's if they fail in the pros.

That said, I probably have a pretty extreme opinion and I'd love to hear some other opinions for both sides.
You go to/work at UGA?

And on the issue, I lean towards no most of the time.
__________________

Quote:
Originally Posted by Helen Lowrie Marshall
“ Aim for a star, and keep your sights high! With a heart full of faith within, your feet on the ground and your eyes in the sky. ”
King Kai Guy is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-31-2014, 02:10 AM   #7 (permalink)
Learning to break kayfabe
 
LlamaFromTheCongo's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2014
Location: California
Posts: 234
LlamaFromTheCongo 50 - 100
Default Re: College Athletes, Are They Employees?

Definitely not employees. They do not need to get compensated beyond the usual full rides they get
__________________

for Paige, BNB,(FUCKING SWAGGER!), Bo Dallas, BROCK LESNAR! and The Wyatt Family
LlamaFromTheCongo is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-31-2014, 07:29 AM   #8 (permalink)
DEZ
 
MrMister's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: The Book of Love
Posts: 26,684
MrMister 24001 - 24500MrMister 24001 - 24500MrMister 24001 - 24500MrMister 24001 - 24500MrMister 24001 - 24500MrMister 24001 - 24500MrMister 24001 - 24500MrMister 24001 - 24500MrMister 24001 - 24500MrMister 24001 - 24500MrMister 24001 - 24500
Default Re: College Athletes, Are They Employees?

Yeah they should get paid. These are exploited workers in a billion dollar industry. I mean they get paid already. Let's just be honest about it.
__________________
:GARRETT
MrMister is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-31-2014, 12:15 PM   #9 (permalink)
Asking SCOTT STEINER for Wrestling Advice
 
Dr. Rhett Henley's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2014
Location: Sunnyvale Trailer Park
Posts: 310
Dr. Rhett Henley 501 - 1000Dr. Rhett Henley 501 - 1000Dr. Rhett Henley 501 - 1000Dr. Rhett Henley 501 - 1000Dr. Rhett Henley 501 - 1000Dr. Rhett Henley 501 - 1000
Default Re: College Athletes, Are They Employees?

I don't think they can pay but the NCAA should cover post-college medical insurance for injuries incurred while a "student-athlete" as well as pay premiums on insurance for basic supplemental insurance for these same athletes. High roller prospects can get their own high-dollar coverage if they are likely headed for a NFL pay day.
__________________
Wardrobe by Coach.
Dr. Rhett Henley is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-31-2014, 12:48 PM   #10 (permalink)
Working on my abs
 
GothicBohemian's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2012
Posts: 2,989
GothicBohemian 5001 - 5500GothicBohemian 5001 - 5500GothicBohemian 5001 - 5500GothicBohemian 5001 - 5500GothicBohemian 5001 - 5500GothicBohemian 5001 - 5500GothicBohemian 5001 - 5500GothicBohemian 5001 - 5500GothicBohemian 5001 - 5500GothicBohemian 5001 - 5500GothicBohemian 5001 - 5500
Default Re: College Athletes, Are They Employees?

I know that varsity athletes at the university I attended were not technically employees, but we received money in other ways. Sometimes it was in the form of being overpaid for a very slack job through the school, for others it came from a local business that put members of the top teams on the payroll at bars and restaurants, though none of them were working shifts. There were always other perks buried into ordinary costs that were waved.

But that’s not the US, and funding, health care and the like is quite different here. I guess it could depend on the sport – I certainly had time and money for anything I wanted to do (I had an actual job as well) but my athletic responsibilities were limited to three hours daily practice and only a few events per month. That’s not the same as what I expect a top NCAA basketball or football player would sacrifice.
GothicBohemian is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply



Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are On


VerticalSports
Baseball Forum Golf Forum Boxing Forum Snowmobile Forum
Basketball Forum Soccer Forum MMA Forum PWC Forum
Football Forum Cricket Forum Wrestling Forum ATV Forum
Hockey Forum Volleyball Forum Paintball Forum Snowboarding Forum
Tennis Forum Rugby Forums Lacrosse Forum Skiing Forums
Copyright (C) Verticalscope Inc Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.2
Powered by vBulletin Copyright © 2000-2009 Jelsoft Enterprises Limited.
vBCredits v1.4 Copyright ©2007, PixelFX Studios