I find Carmella to be super cringe-worthy, she doesn't seem genuine. I honestly don't understand her appeal. At least she isn't being shoehorned into Enzo & Cass anymore.
If they want Carmella to have any chance, she's gotta drop the Enzo/Cass promo style. She should have dropped that in NXT already. But since they didn't have her drop it (and apparently aren't planning to), I don't really think staying in NXT would've made Carmella better.
She should have revamped her character for the MR. I've struggled to tolerate her as a character and on the mic since she was split up from Enzo/Cass, tbh, and it was predictably a dud on SD. She needs to stop trying to be Enzo for obvious reasons.
I almost think she'd be more successful as a heel.
Considering how bad she is on the mic, I don't know why they still have her doing that cringeworthy intro of hers every week.
Also, as a face with her current schtick, there's literally zero chance of her getting over on Smackdown. Enzo's over because he's genuinely funny, cuts entertaining promos and actually displays charisma beyond the stupid catchphrases.
She does have some things going for her like her little moonwalk and other funny mannerisms but its minuscule in comparison to Enzo. Plus, even in NXT, it took her a long time until she was accepted as a face and on the main roster you don't that amount of time or chances.
Her slowly transitioning into a delusional heel that thinks the crowds loves her while going through her obnoxious schtick every week would do wonders for her.
Considering how bad she is on the mic, I don't know why they still have her doing that cringeworthy intro of hers every week.
Also, as a face with her current schtick, there's literally zero chance of her getting over on Smackdown. Enzo's over because he's genuinely funny, cuts entertaining promos and actually displays charisma beyond the stupid catchphrases.
She does have some things going for her like her little moonwalk and other funny mannerisms but its minuscule in comparison to Enzo. Plus, even in NXT, it took her a long time until she was accepted as a face and on the main roster you don't that amount of time or chances.
Her slowly transitioning into a delusional heel that thinks the crowds loves her while going through her obnoxious schtick every week would do wonders for her.
She gets on my damn nerves. She's fine in the ring but the gimmick is so obnoxiously forced it kills her for me. She needs to find her own thing, especially since she's not even teamed with Enzo and Cass anymore.
It's everything I feared. This gimmick was never any good even when she had the protection of the Enzo association.
It sucks 'cause she's a likable, charismatic (and not iritating) person outside of her gimmick. The random periscope clips and other "outside" stuff demonstrates exactly who Carmella is and should be on TV.
The only way this current gimmick works is as an annoying heel.
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Related Threads
?
?
?
?
?
Wrestling Forum
23.4M posts
266.5K members
Since 2002
A forum community dedicated to all Wrestling enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about WWE, AEW, Ring of Honor, Impact and all forms of professional and amateur wrestling.