[Da Silva]

Is the difference the fact that the background is quite dark in the first few and very bright in the fourth picture?

[TheRainKing]

Ok, just for you.

[Da Silva]

When he's in the ring with any of those people he doesn't look out of place and that's the important thing.

Selective stills count for fuck all.

[TheRainKing]

If you say so.

I'm not saying Punk wouldn't be able to feature in the attitude era at all, only that he wouldn't be a big star.

Even if his size wasn't holding him back, he would still lack the character needed to get over with the fans.

[Dexter Morgan]

Never came here cuz I don't really care about ratings, but this is just like the GOAT and Punk/Rock discussion thread. Pointless thread.

[Kabraxal]

Originally Posted by TheRainKing

It's not about height, it's about physique, presence, and looking like a star.







------------




Come on guys, is it that hard to tell the difference?

Punk manages to have presenxe without having bulky muscles... that's what I notice.

[Phenom]

Originally Posted by Kabraxal

Punk manages to have presenxe without having bulky muscles... that's what I notice.

For me, Punk has very little presence, and doesn't look like a credible main eventer. He looks mismatched against most of his opponents. I still think that he should be in the mid card.

[Dexter Morgan]

Punk is well above midcard level. You're saying he is no better than Kofi or Cesaro? Please, that is just ridiculous.

[Phenom]

Originally Posted by K.W.H.

Punk is well above midcard level. You're saying he is no better than Kofi or Cesaro? Please, that is just ridiculous.

That's exactly what I'm saying, and I don't see why it's so ridiculous. Compare the physiques, presence and movesets of Punk, Kofi and Cesaro, and you'll see that Punk is much more suited to the mid card. Against natural main eventers like Rock, he simply doesn't cut it, IMHO. The Rain King's post above serves to highlight this beautifully.

[Dexter Morgan]

To each his own I guess. Size isn't everything, but okay. Just don't see how Punk, who has beaten Cena over and over, can't stand up to Rock, who has only beaten Cena once.