[Bubz]

Nervosa bringing back the Eddie HATE~!

I've seen Davey/Elgin and enjoyed it quite a lot both times. Honestly maybe because of the commentary and crowd reaction, because put that match infront of a dead crowd and with Prazak or someone commentating and I bet I'd like it so much less.

[Obfuscation]

I hated both Davey vs Edwards matches & Davey vs Elgin after the first watch. I'm the exception to the rule.

[Nervosa]

Originally Posted by Stocking Filled w/HAYLEY JOY~!

I hated both Davey vs Edwards matches & Davey vs Elgin after the first watch. I'm the exception to the rule.

I don't think you're an exception at all. I think anyone who hates Davey/Elgin HAS TO hate Davey/Edwards. Your position makes perfect sense to me.

The people I don't understand are the ones ok with Eddie/Davey and not ok with Elgin/Davey.

[Bubz]

Elgin/Davey was a hell of a lot better than Davey/Eddie. I liked Davey/Eddie loads back when it happened. Watched it maybe about 4 months ago or something and yeah, it is bad. Nervosa did you see their Final Battle rematch? Not sure when I've ever hated watching wrestling that much before.

[Nervosa]

Originally Posted by Bubz

Elgin/Davey was a hell of a lot better than Davey/Eddie. I liked Davey/Eddie loads back when it happened. Watched it maybe about 4 months ago or something and yeah, it is bad. Nervosa did you see their Final Battle rematch? Not sure when I've ever hated watching wrestling that much before.

See, that makes sense to me. Even if you hate Elgin/Davey, you have to admit its better than Eddie/Davey.

No, I did not watch the Final Battle rematch. I heard 'BITW was way better' and decided there's nothing in the world that could make me want a second helping of that shit.

[Obfuscation]

Originally Posted by Nervosa

I don't think you're an exception at all. I think anyone who hates Davey/Elgin HAS TO hate Davey/Edwards. Your position makes perfect sense to me.

The people I don't understand are the ones ok with Eddie/Davey and not ok with Elgin/Davey.

I've seen much more love for Davey/Elgin than I have any of the Davey/Eddie matches.

[Nervosa]

Originally Posted by Stocking Filled w/HAYLEY JOY~!

I've seen much more love for Davey/Elgin than I have any of the Davey/Eddie matches.

O man, you should have seen last year's version of this thread. HO-LY-SHEEEEEEET people loved Eddie/Davey. I was absolutely surrounded. I needed a long break after those arguments. It probably got more 'match of the year' votes than anything else besides Cena/Punk.

I needed a long sabbatical from this board after that period.

[Obfuscation]

Weird. I don't remember any praise. By the time Final battle rolled around and happened, that rematch was met with great & furious anger. I guess the aura of BITW rubbed off by the winter months.

[septurum]

Originally Posted by Bubz

I've seen Davey/Elgin and enjoyed it quite a lot both times. Honestly maybe because of the commentary .

I think Nigel is a major reason for that match being so good.

[Obfuscation]

Nigel puts them over like a BOSS. Even on commentary he manages to put matches on a higher level.

It reminds me of Final Battle 2011 when his commentary was the highlight of the entire show.