Peter, Peter, you're a ....!
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Winchester, VA
Favourite(s): The Phenomenal One, THE MAN, & El Ingobernable
Re: ROH on SBG Discussion Thread
As far as comparing Sinclair to HDNet, I think Sinclair is the easier show to watch because of the way it's setup and there's more than just matches. Promos, vid packages, etc. It actually fells like a wrestling show, not just an hour of recorded matches with an occasional highlight from an iPPV or something. That being said, match quality on HDNet kicks the shit out of Sinclair. One year into the show so far, I think I have 3 matches at the *** 3/4 level (Davey/Roddy World Title, Lethal/Generico I & Davey/Eddie IV) with nothing dipping into that 4-star level. One year into HDNet shows and I have seven **** matches at the minimum. I think a lot of it has to do with the booking as well but I don't think a 'Best of Sinclair' DVD will ever be as good as an HDNet disc & match quality is what I care about most.