Learning to break kayfabe
Join Date: Feb 2012
Re: The 2011 MOTYC Thread
I'm assuming you mean the BITW match, and the only way that was five stars is if you rate out of 20.
seriously, eight posts before you come in saying it was "a pure *****" I explained fairly succinctly why the match wasn't good. I've gone far more in depth earlier in this thread, and while you're obviously new and I can't expect you to read back to June and July, you should at least read back to yesterday, and maybe try making an argument that responds to mine instead of just asserting your opinion with no support.
there's actually much less room for subjectivity in critical analysis than most people suspect. I guess technically everything is subjective, but there are conventions that are conventions for a reason, and it's very easy to make accurate objective statements given those conventions.
You explained why you didn't like it. That doesn't mean no-one else can think of it highly. I explained why I liked it and you explained why you didn't. I think it's a classic. You don't. None of our opinions are fact. It's subjective, you know.