Re: Official Indy DVD Thread
As much as I absolutely love Gargano, I can't picture him making it big in the WWE. He has all the tools except for the look. Yes, I know Daniel Bryan and CM Punk don't have "the look" but they worked a lot longer to establish themselves and I firmly believe (though it is certainly arguable) that their reputations on the indies and their fanbase from the indies helped initially establish them in WWE. Gargano is not at that point yet. At this point all I can see is him at Trent Baretta status...hopefully I am wrong though because he is a heck of a talent.
I for one would actually prefer Gargano in TNA. I am really enjoying the direction the company has taken as of late since going live, and I could see Gargano as a good fit. Though with so much talent, now might not be the right time for him. Unless they put him in the X-Division, but again with all of the talent they just brought in it might not be the right time though I see him as a good replacement for Alex Shelley...able to play a cocky young heel or a cool babyface.
Ideally for now, as a fan of his, I would like to see Gargano remain on the indies. I would love to see him make his way to PWG.