Regularly Beating Up James Ellsworth
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Halifax, NS
Re: Official Indy DVD Thread
Yeah, I looked at every review in the ratings thread and I think everyone had it at **** or ****1/4 except one ****1/2 and one ***1/2. I guess I was expecting it to be so much bigger and more epic than it was. I mean, it was freaking Aries vs. Shelley, it was possibly the biggest match ROH could deliver at the time, and it just felt like another Aries title defense, only against someone he didn't like. A good match, but not what Aries vs. Shelley could have been.
It also didn't help that it felt like an afterthought during the show, with Punk's promo cutting out Shelley's entrance, and Homicide coming out immediately after the match ended.
This is the other wrestling section. It's still fake to us.