Thread Tools

vivalabrave · 04-11-2008, 12:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leonardo LunchBoX

I agree with it 110%

I didn't think it was as good as everyone rates it.

Neither did I. I've seen it 3 times (third time with a friend who was pretty bored with it, although we did just sit through 3 hours of Mania) and I can only give it ***3/4. Still good though. I didn't love the finish with Taker getting the title with *Cole mode on* THAT MOVE!!! *Cole mode off*

Quote:

Originally Posted by KeepItFresh

This thread isn't moving. So I thought I'd post my top 10 matches thus far this year. Thoughts? Whatever? Nonsense?

MOTY List:
3. Roderick Strong v.s Nigel McGuniess- ROH Without Remorse ****1/4

WOW. Now I'm really looking forward to seeing this match. Highest I've seen someone give it was like ***3/4.

**Sephiroth** · 04-11-2008, 12:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by vivalabrave

Neither did I. I've seen it 3 times (third time with a friend who was pretty bored with it, although we did just sit through 3 hours of Mania) and I can only give it ***3/4. Still good though. I didn't love the finish with Taker getting the title with *Cole mode on* THAT MOVE!!! *Cole mode off*

WOW. Now I'm really looking forward to seeing this match. Highest I've seen someone give it was like ***3/4.

i saw it live and initially thought it was ****. haven't seen it since then tho

**KeepItFresh** · 04-11-2008, 03:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by vivalabrave

WOW. Now I'm really looking forward to seeing this match. Highest I've seen someone give it was like ***3/4.

I'm a huge Roderick Strong fan, so that may have inflated the score. The match also had a great main event feel throughout with Roderick actually looking like he might win which always adds to these matches.

**Ownage™** · 04-12-2008, 05:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KeepItFresh

This thread isn't moving. So I thought I'd post my top 10 matches thus far this year. Thoughts? Whatever? Nonsense?

MOTY List:

1. Shawn Michaels v.s Ric Flair- WrestleMania 24 ****3/4
2. The Undertaker v.s Edge- Wrestlemania 24 ****1/4
3. Roderick Strong v.s Nigel McGuniess- ROH Without Remorse ****1/4
4. Christain Cage v.s Kurt Angle- Aganist All Odds ****1/4
5. Raw Elimination Chamber- No Way Out ****1/4
6. Bryan Danielson v.s Tyler Black- Breakout ****
7. Christian Cage v.s Kurt Angle- Final Resolution ****
8. Kevin Steen v.s Go Shiozaki- Eye Of The Storm ***3/4-****
9. Money In The Bank IV- Wrestlemania 24 ***3/4
10. Christian Cage v.s Kurt Angle- TNA Impact, Cage Match ***3/4

Still need to watch ROH's 6th Anniversary show. Considering how good Nigel/Danielson matches usually are this should change.

Angle/Cage from Final Res > the cage match on Impact.

**KeepItFresh** · 04-12-2008, 02:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ownage™

Angle/Cage from Final Res > the cage match on Impact.

Yeah I have the Final Resolution match at **** as my #7 and Impact cage match is at ***3/4 at #10.

**Ownage™** · 04-12-2008, 06:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KeepItFresh

Yeah I have the Final Resolution match at **** as my #7 and Impact cage match is at ***3/4 at #10.

I totally didn't see that

doubledeez · 04-12-2008, 07:05 PM

Anyone got Meltzer's ratings of Mania yet, the Observer sites said the issue with the ratings was supposed to come out this week.

**KeepItFresh** · 04-12-2008, 07:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by doubledeez

Anyone got Meltzer's ratings of Mania yet, the Observer sites said the issue with the ratings was supposed to come out this week.

Someone just posted them in the WWE DVD discussion thread.

**Taroostyles** · 04-12-2008, 07:38 PM

Yeah someone in the WWE DVD Thread said that he gave HBK/Flair ***1/2, MITB ***1/4, Taker/Edge ****1/4, and HHH/Cena/Orton ***1/2.

I knew he wouldn't go high on HBK/Flair, but I didn't think he'd go that low either.

doubledeez · 04-12-2008, 09:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Taroostyles

Yeah someone in the WWE DVD Thread said that he gave HBK/Flair ***1/2, MITB ***1/4, Taker/Edge ****1/4, and HHH/Cena/Orton ***1/2.

I knew he wouldn't go high on HBK/Flair, but I didn't think he'd go that low either.

Wow I'm shocked at that that's ridiculous Flair/HBK deserved at least ****+. I definitely just lost some credibility for Meltzer. I think he has some kind of WWE bias and a secret fetish for Japanese wrestling (not that I don't like Japanese wrestling he just overrates a lot of them).