[Tom Ormo]

I have this year's Rumble at around *** 3/4.

[ROH]

My fav thread

[Andy3000]

So far, having seen nothing from Japan or any indies, my favourite match is HBK/Kennedy from RAW a couple weeks ago. Apparently I'm the only one who loved that match though.

[Taroostyles]

Personally, I wouldn't go any higher than ***1/2 on the Rumble.

Way too much of a clusterfuck for my liking. The eliminations didn't feel well paced to me, there was no elims for like 15 minutes and then 3 in about 30 seconds.

I liked last year's Rumble alot more.

[Hajime No Blasko]

Rumble was a solid *** 1/2. Then Cena came and made it ****.

[sirdilznik]

Originally Posted by Taroostyles

Personally, I wouldn't go any higher than ***1/2 on the Rumble.

Way too much of a clusterfuck for my liking. The eliminations didn't feel well paced to me, there was no elims for like 15 minutes and then 3 in about 30 seconds.

I liked last year's Rumble alot more.

I agree for the most part. A few things took away from the match for me: The whole Hornswoggle BS and Chavo being a participant left me with a bad taste in my mouth. The John Cena shocker was however really, really awesome and it raised the overall score in my mind to *** 3/4.

[huthutraul]

PWG All-Star Weekend 6 night 1: Low-Ki vs. Danielson for the world title, I gave ****1/4-****1/2.

Just an amazing match live and the best I have seen so far this year

[Benjo™]

Originally Posted by sirdilznik

I agree for the most part. A few things took away from the match for me: The whole Hornswoggle BS and Chavo being a participant left me with a bad taste in my mouth. The John Cena shocker was however really, really awesome and it raised the overall score in my mind to *** 3/4.

When Chavo entered, it did make me laugh for a good while.

Hornswoggle was a complete waste of time in the Rumble.

Overall the Rumble was ***3/4 for me as well, the crowd really helped it as well because everyone (except Elijah Burke) got a good reaction which is cool to see plus Cena at the end was 1 of the best surprises WWE have done in a long time.

[-GP-]

Originally Posted by -Blaskonio Inoki-

Rumble was a solid *** 1/2. Then Cena came and made it ****.

spot-on imo.
didn't touch last year's Rumble in terms of pure rumble match quality, but the ending did elevate it a lot

[Tom Ormo]

Yeah Cena did help this years Rumble alot although the ending of last year's Rumble with Taker and HBK going head to head was amazing.