[StraightEdge]

I Agree with You both, The brawl was just awesome. *** doesnt justify the match at all.

[Jack Evans 187]

I also agree. **** for me. And you should'nt have skipped the Tag Title match. It was really good. ***3/4 I believe.

On a side note, SCOH II came today. I'll have ratings in the next couple days.

[wwefanatic411]

my In Your Face review:
Sterling Keenan + Jason Blade vs The Briscoes- *3/4
Jimmy Rave w/ Prince Nanna vs Davey Richards- **1/4
ROH Tag Team Titles Colt Cabana + Nigel McGuinness vs Generation Next- ***-***1/4
Jimmy Jacobs w/ Lacey vs BJ Whitmer- **1/2
ROH Top of the Class Trophy Mitch Franklin vs Shane Hagadorn- *1/2
Adam Pearce vs Claudio Castagnoli- **1/4
Homicide vs Chris Hero- **1/2-**3/4
Three Way Dance Samoa Joe vs KENTA vs Bryan Danielson- ***3/4

I know that im probably going to catch some heat for this review, but a lot of these matches seemed like they were missing something imo(Jacobs/Whitmer, Pearce/Castagnol, etc). Jacobs/Whitmer didnt flow to well and was too short imo. even the matches that i gave a high rating to still seemed to like they could have been better. the bonus FIP match at the end was a pleasent surprise, though. please comment this review, because i want to see if others feel the same way.

[El Conquistador]

Originally Posted by sephy37

i have We're No Joke. it's good, but not great. Low Ki vs. Necro is awesome, so is Hero vs. Milano and Generico vs. Delirious and 9 Man TLC. the rest was ok. Marek Brave steals the show for literally going nowhere :P.

i preferred the TPI last year and the double dvd is the one you should be recommending to everyone, not We're No Joke.

Bingo, I totally agree with you except for Hero/Milano being great. There's a bunch of shows I'd recommend over "We're No Joke", it's not all that great. The show in general was just way too spotty, it didn't live up to the MEGA hype it receives on a regular basis. From this year, buy "Payback, Pain, & Agony" and "Hurt". I thought they were both better than "We're No Joke". A couple other DVD's that you should buy would be "Sunday Blood Sunday" and "April Bloodshowers 2007: The Final Chapter".

As for the Manhattan Mayhem Tag Match that people seem to be judging, I gave it ***2/3. Not quite worthy enough of the recognition it receives on a consistent basis, but it certainly isn't anything short of good.

[Thisskateboarding]

Can anyone please post star ratings for
Chikara Tag World Gran Prix 2006 Nights 1,2,3?

Also what show is it that Punk/Hero have there 93 minute match?

And are there any must have recent shows from IWA:MS this year besides Hurt?

[Platt]

Originally Posted by Thisskateboarding

Can anyone please post star ratings for
Chikara Tag World Gran Prix 2006 Nights 1,2,3?

Also what show is it that Punk/Hero have there 93 minute match?

And are there any must have recent shows from IWA:MS this year besides Hurt?

Punk/Hero was from IWA:MS When Hero Met Punk

[Thisskateboarding]

Thanks is the video quality any good? Ive got a match of theirs from IWA:MS Best of CM Punk and its shot from in the crowd and looks terrible.

[watts63]

Originally Posted by wwefanatic411

my In Your Face review:
Sterling Keenan + Jason Blade vs The Briscoes- *3/4
Jimmy Rave w/ Prince Nanna vs Davey Richards- **1/4
ROH Tag Team Titles Colt Cabana + Nigel McGuinness vs Generation Next- ***-***1/4
Jimmy Jacobs w/ Lacey vs BJ Whitmer- **1/2
ROH Top of the Class Trophy Mitch Franklin vs Shane Hagadorn- *1/2
Adam Pearce vs Claudio Castagnoli- **1/4
Homicide vs Chris Hero- **1/2-**3/4
Three Way Dance Samoa Joe vs KENTA vs Bryan Danielson- ***3/4

I know that im probably going to catch some heat for this review, but a lot of these matches seemed like they were missing something imo(Jacobs/Whitmer, Pearce/Castagnol, etc). Jacobs/Whitmer didnt flow to well and was too short imo. even the matches that i gave a high rating to still seemed to like they could have been better. the bonus FIP match at the end was a pleasent surprise, though. please comment this review, because i want to see if others feel the same way.

I gave KENTA vs. Danielson vs. Joe **** & gave Homicide/Hero ***1/2. Also Briscoes vs. Sterling/Keenan **3/4.

[CMAngle33]

Originally Posted by Future Star

thats it?, i enjoyed the brawl type of this, i would say around ****

I'll take another look. I watched it the night before and put down the ratings in the morning.

[StraightEdge]

Anyone know if Styles Vs Joe from "Spring Slam 2" is Anygood?