Originally Posted by Hailsabin
Well anyways, sorry to R_O_H, but i am not taking your Star Ratings seriously anymore, you seem to rate things way too low most of the time and this isn't the first time these guys have had a complaint, sure its opinion but every single time, geez I don't know anymore. Especially when i read your review on BOLA 06, every person that has it on here, gave most the of matches *** or higher but he just made the whole thing sound poor. I know its harsh what i just said but whenevery time you post Star ratings and everyone gets on your case, i just can't believe there right.
Everyone on here gave most of the matches *** or more. I didn't.
In other words I just didn't agree with other people. That makes me a bad reviewer does it?
I don't think I made the whole thing sound poor at all. As an overall score for all 3 night I gave it 8/10 and put "strong recomendation". Look at the "last wrestling match I watched" in my sig. That's alot higher than others gave it.
You think my star ratings are too low? That's fine. I just realised one time I was giving a match a high rating just because I liked the wrestlers, and it was actually a bad match. So I started to give stricter ratings. A *** rating in my book is good, **1/2 is solid.
Honor what you said is right, I am in the wrong.
The thing is though, I just can't get into Samoa Joe matches. For me to give a match ****+ that match (my criteria here) will have to keep me entertained and not bored for however long it's on for. Yes, I know it's easier for a 20 minute match to keep you more interested than a 60 minute match, but still I got really bored watching Joe/Dragon.
I think it's mostly just becuase the match got lots of ***** claims etc. and when I watched it I didn't feel that way. Just a case of going in with too high expectations.
I know I can't take a match down disliking a worker etc, but for however long Joe uses the same moves over and over I will not give any of his matches a high rating.
Sorry for a late reply, the time's different here and I had to go to bed...