Re: The 2014 MOTYC Thread
PLEASE do that. As seen on some other sites, it makes the whole function of a MOTYC thread much more useful.
A threshold is not a good idea though. Then it's a nuisance, and you're asking people to follow someone elses criteria for how to rate matches. I don't give out ****+ more than 5-10 times a year, that's what I prefer. I think following the example of similar MOTYC threads is best, and people here should be nominating matches and voting yes if they agree and want to add their vote to the overall list. Much easier. People can give out their ratings or whatever as they discuss the match but it's not a part of making an overall concensus list.
I guess I can only expect so much honesty and reason from two guys who just get everything they want. Imagine if Willy Wonka opened his factory and Veruca Salt won every Golden Ticket. That’d be the WWE main event scene. CM Punk would be Charlie, his Grandpa would be Colt Cabana and they’d have to fart a bunch to keep from being chewed up in Vince McMahon’s ceiling fans.