Pet Sounds is incredible (so far anyways). Can see this getting many plays from me.
Gonna check out some of the Deftones albums. I only heard their self-titled and Diamond Eyes in their entirety. I think I heard songs here and there from Saturday Night Wrist and White Pony. Gonna start with White Pony first.
Downloaded most of the stuff from the alt rock category, and loved all of it so far. Thought Frengers was my favourite album of the lot, but Third Eye Blind (the album) is just phenomenal. Is the rest of their stuff high quality too? Would be interested to know if Mew and The Manchester Orchestra are consistently good with all of their albums too. Thanks.
I've only really gone through the alt rock category thus far. I'll have a look through the punk, post-hardcore and indie stuff soon too, plus some of the essentials I don't already have. Would have more if my internet wasn't total crap.