I'd rather nobody have got it in Indy tbh if we're seriously 'rewarding' sXe for his play in that game. He went against his win condition when he was town and it's not like he had to do anything to win as survivor after that
I honestly don't remember who actually played the best in my game. From what I remember it was an overall good effort from town.
That and scum screwed up when I gave them a police officer wrestler as a fake claim, put a miller in the game, let them ask a "Yes" or "No" question every night, and they still didn't figure out that there was no cop.