[Faraday]

Originally Posted by Anark

And who is it pretty obvious that you're town to?

Well it should be obvious to just about anyone? But basically any of the players who've played with me recently that are pretty good will be able to tell I'm town here. I'd say that as scum anyway, so it's kind of w/e.

I was going to make another post about you where I was questioning why you kept asking other people for their opinions, when there was fuck all to go on at the moment and so you were basically asking for opinions on fluff, but it occurred to me that soliciting opinions on any gameplay can lead to more readable material.

Well it's not like I'm avoiding giving plenty of opinions of my own - I want people to take stances and force them to actually contribute, if not Day 2 becomes Day 1 and there's nothing to go on.


Paco, PHEN0M isn't a new player. I mean I get your point in that so far I've attacked newish player but then most of those posting are relatively new so far and I don't even think McLovin is scum - but attacking someone for something is a good way to start the game.

I'm pretty confident in most of my town reads, even if multi scum I think a decent amount of the tells don't rely on genuine scumhunting so are applicable.

[The_Answer]

Originally Posted by PacoAwesome

@ Farady, "Planting his seeds"= spreading influence in the game by already targeting new players in a rather aggressive fashion. That's what I meant for it to be interpreted as anyways, although I was mainly being humorous. However, to me it doesn't make you scum, I just wouldn't be surprised if you flipped scum is all.

Reads so far:
Faraday- Is playing fairly town imo although I found his first posts rather weird for some strange reason. Could be something, could be nothing.

Cloverleaf- seems pretty town so with his posts so far
King Kenny- The boobs in his sig says he is town.
McLovin It- I don't know how he normally plays, but he seems a little off to me with his responses to those voting him scum. I don't think he is scum atm, but not looking very town to me.
Ziggler Mark- Ziggy being Ziggy. Being completely unorthodox in his playing as usual. He always plays a little scummy in his games as far as I'm concerned even when he is town
Nov- Playing very town atm, keeping an eye on him though
Phenom- Same as Nov, although him claiming Nov edited one of his post when Nov did no such thing is a little strange and probably worth looking into on Day 1.
Froot- Obvious town.

Anyone I didn't mention is neutral to me as I don't have reads on them

I'd agree with most of your assessments, although I haven't played with ziggy but I have a feeling he could be scum, again maybe I'm not use to his play. Faraday I'm thinking town too but with him you never know cuz he tends to play the same whether town or scum. As for me, there was only a few people posting, thought that would give me a chance to be able to get a read on someone, chose Nov and checked his reaction. If I truly thought he had edited and was scum I would still be pushing right now.

[Faraday]

Originally Posted by Anark

It's the name of the town aligned team, it's in the OP and the PMs we receive. You're trying to say it's awkward that someone mentioned that, but your post saying it was awkward felt awkward to me.

Right, I think this is one of those you agree/don't situations w/r/t PHEN0M's post. I think the name of the town alignment is kind of an awkward thing/weird to remember so typing town feels more natural to me, in general. I'm not neccessarily sure it makes PHEN0M guilty - there are parts of his content I like and I like to think I'll be able to read him if we both survive long enough anyway. I just think it was kind of weird, despite being the actual alignment.

[Anark]

Originally Posted by Faraday

I want people to take stances and force them to actually contribute, if not Day 2 becomes Day 1 and there's nothing to go on.

Which I agree is good stuff, hence why I haven't voted.

Originally Posted by Faraday

Right, I think this is one of those you agree/don't situations w/r/t PHEN0M's post. I think the name of the town alignment is kind of an awkward thing/weird to remember so typing town feels more natural to me, in general. I'm not neccessarily sure it makes PHEN0M guilty - there are parts of his content I like and I like to think I'll be able to read him if we both survive long enough anyway. I just think it was kind of weird, despite being the actual alignment.

I think Burbank was the name of Danny Glover's family cat in the Lethal Weapon films, something like that anyway, that's why it stood out to me.

[Faraday]

Originally Posted by Anark

What other reasons were you hoping to extract from him?

The actual reason? Since it was impossible to have "just a feeling" at that point?

[Anark]

Originally Posted by Cloverleaf

^ The beginnings of Anark tunneling the person with the most suspisions cast upon them.

Not sure if this is a scum tell though?

Asking a few questions and having a conversation isn't really tunneling someone.

[Gambit]

Tbh Ziggler probably did just have a feeling and felt like Taylor might be scum. So it is a completely random vote. Ziggler do you have any reads yet? Anyone else you have a feeling on ?

[Faraday]

Originally Posted by PHEN0M

If I truly thought he had edited and was scum I would still be pushing right now.

Huh, you mean you'd push as scum regardless of whether you believed it or if you were scum and believed it you'd push?

[King Kenny]

I'm off for like two hours to sleep. so far obby has seems weird and faraday looks non town to me. it's eerily similar to a previous game where no-one follow ed and he was scum. I understand you're a smart player faraday which is why I've been questioning you to see your reaxtions

[Anark]

Originally Posted by Faraday

The actual reason? Since it was impossible to have "just a feeling" at that point?

But Taylor hadn't posted yet, so there couldn't possibly be a reason. If it was someone new asking that, then fair enough, but even though we haven't played much together, I have heard that you are rather good, so it seemed odd to me that you wouldn't just assume it's a random vote based off of nothing.

It couldn't possible be based off of anything. Unless there's some kind of role which gives info out the second a game has started, but I know not of such a role.