Right. Do me a favor.
Look at my posts from day one in CL mafia.
Then compare them to day one posts in this game.
It's not coasting on day fucking two.
It sure can be, Mikey, esp. in a game this active with so much meaningful interaction on day 1. I notice my comment has lit a fire under your ass. I'm wondering if it's because you're scum trying to look town or you're town.
The wagon on me is baseless and totally stupid. Sxe even admitted he purposely found the fluff posts to use as a case. EVERYONE has fluff posts in a big game like this. I bet I could do the exact same to everyone in this game.
Onto your reads.my opnions of your reads:
I disagree here. I don't think obby is town. I think he's the scum watcher. From the start his play has been all over the place, and I don't believe his claim either it looks like a fake-claim. I had a scummy vibe from him since it started, and it hasn't gone away. Hence why I'm voting him today.
I actually agree with you here. I haven't really noticed the difference in his scum/town meta, but he doesn't seem to be doing much scum hunting at the moment, playing a little bit conservative (sp?). How did he play in star wars? I missed the majority of that since I died early.
Disagree again here. I don't think christo is scummy for pushing the wagon a sloppy obby. Sloppyness can go hand in hand with being scummy you know. I need to read back on christos posts to get a more solid read on him, but in accordance with this quoted post, I don't find him scummy for that. A lot of people are comparing/looking back at previous games during this game for assistance it seems.
Definitely agree here. There isn't much else to add as you covered it quite well. Her activity + her substance in her posting can be directed towards her scum meta. She often posts more when she's town and doesn't play as aggresively (albeit it looks FAKE). I'd like to see more substance from here. I'm not 100% sure she's scum yet, but I'm leaning that way at the moment.
I'm undecided on Nov. In the beginning when only a few of us were posting it did seem like he was playing a careless game, he did share some of the same thoughts as me (such as Faraday being scum). I can't remember playing with Nov years ago. But..when he was scum in the last game (cant remember the game), his style of play was a lot different then it is now. That might be him being scum changing his play, or he might actually have a distinctive difference in his scum and town styles of play. I'm leaning town at the moment, but he is always someone to look out for.
IMPULSE is hard to read in my opinion. I know how he plays as scum, but he could always change his style of play to suit the game. This game he started off with fluff, then phenom lit a fire up his ass and he started to produce thoughts + substance in his posting. I'll lean town at the moment, but again he's someone to watch.
I've already given my opinions on Faraday during this game. I still think he's non town. Just a general vibe I'm getting off him + plus his aggressive and defensive play mashed in together. He's pretty much calling all the shots too at the moment, almost "running" the game so to speak. He's an intelligent mafia poster, and can easily be masking his scummyness with a different style of play. He's incredibly active too. I'm not sure that that matters because I think he's been active as both scum and town before. Only a few people seemed to follow the faraday lynch so at the moment my vote stays on obby.
Onto your last post:
I agree sxe is town.
Like how he's playing in this game. Kenny, you surprised me with this. This makes me think more so that you are town. You should keep this level of contribution up. I think you're a more capable player than many of us realize.
shocked at that post from kenny.
faraday should come in an admit that i'm a better judge of player's skill b/c ziggler couldn't produce what kenny just did.
i think that's town kenny. i don't think scum kenny would put himself out there, at least not during this phase.
So am I. The second part made me laugh. Yeah, that definitely seems like a town post from him.
i want tat to clarify how i perfectly set up nov to be scum and provide examples of me making town players look like scum.
nov admitted he did some stupid stuff on day one. i jump on stupid stuff, it's how magic positioned me for a lynch when i jumped on mclovin's botch role requests in CL.
It's this post that I was thinking of when I made that post last night:
When Doc made his post he was yawning. Did you know yawning is contagious? This sleepiness is robbing me of my senses so I'm going to go ahead and vote Doc, here's the funny part I don't suspect Doc. I'm only voting Doc b/c all the cool kids are doing it, let's also disregard the fact that my earlier post said I found Faraday suspicious, but I haven't followed up on that and I'm now willing to follow the wagon my suspect started.
What the fuck, Nov? Bullshit at this being a logical town thought process for a competent player.
It reminded me of when you pushed the LC wagon on day 1 of Hunger Games mafia. But rereading it now, you're more 'real' here than you were in those posts if I recall them correctly and I think I misunderstood that push in Hunger Games because I saw you imply later after I made that post that you got LC lynched in that game thinking she was town. Here's that post:
if he somehow flips town then i should stop cornering weaker players. hunger games, champions, and now this would shatter my will to play.
i stopped attacking people for months after the hunger games debacle. i go into the hunger games to protect my sister, volunteer for my sister, only to get my sister lynched on the first day.
If you are implying here that you thought she was scum, since I recall you were Indy and thus could have been scum hunting for real, then I misunderstood your original actions since I thought you had intentionally gotten her lynched since you were non-town.
Kenny, you say you want more substance from me but in the same breath you say the substance I have contributed is fake. Not really sure what you want me to do.
As for my activity, I'm in the top half of posters and have 33 more posts than Titania.
That means nothing since for the most part you always have more posts than me, just look at the last game where we were both town, and a lack of activity isn't a scum-tell for me as it is for you. Not sure why you even brought that up.
all we need is titania and mcqueen and this thread has turn into a christmas mafia scum reunion
I really enjoyed being scum with you in that game. Next time we're scum together, lets not even show up in the game thread but just stay in the QT.
i know some people were criticizing anark for having a singular focus. something about he focuses on one topic, tunnels on and mostly ignores everything. i think that's a town tell for him.
in christmas mafia mcqueen was his scum read from like the beginning of the game. the basis for it was wrong, but he made the right read and he never let go of it. he continued to push it and push it. when he decided to duel he chose his read over damage who got away w/ an awful claim and roy who was caught in lies.
anark being stubborn or stuck on something isn't a scum tell. this could have changed in the last two games, but everyone knows i wasn't around for the majority of those games.
That's a good point and accurate but his play thus far reminds me way more of last game than Christmas mafia. The first Skyfall, Cloverleaf, and Dan noticed it as well. I didn't like him lynching CHAMP just because he was posting the gif. Scum often focus on inconsequential things like that.
anark didn't fuck up your win condition and making it impossible to win. i was going to have to drag titania to 4 players for a win. i was ready to quit the game days prior so there was no way i was letting it go for a couple of more days.
That sounds painful.