TKOK is town, he claimed miller, miller shouldn't ever be a fakeclaim and irrc bigman doesn't give role fakeclaims.
just because Miller isnt a fake claim given by big man doesnt mean a scum player wouldnt claim it. Think about it, claiming miller here is guaranteed to keep you alive for at least a few phases. It's a smart move.
Hypothetically, if TKOK is scum he would know what the scum team was anyway. Why would fake claim being copped a different alignment than the scum team? Once one flips something other than Liverpool aligned he'd be in the firing line straight away.
Why would big put Gerard as Champions aligned in the OP, even if it was a joke, if iot was going to be the scum team. I guess maybe it was because it would be the obvious choice.
My guess could be to throw people off. People who read the football thread would know of the United/Liverpool banter and it could have been a play on his part to fool people. People were already confused as to the theme and big then putting a Liverpool player in the OP and mentioning the 1 player per team rule would easily have people questioning what scum was.
I like the theory personally as it makes sense with a non champions league team being the enemy in a 'champions league' game. The only query surrounds big being a United fan and whether he's thrown a deliberate curveball with people expecting him to bait Liverpool.
I think he claimed fairly early, also it's not really a smart move
every game I've played that has had a miller, theyve died really late...how is it not smart? If you're fake claiming it, it guarantees you can coast. I'm not saying that's what TKOK is doing, but I'm shocked no one has done that yet.
fake claiming miller is risky and unadvisable which is why I used to do it all the time. It's impossible to tell 100%, but because he claimed outright and the flavor made sense I think it's best to let that boy slide.
Shep looks town to me.
CP and Pez are probably gay millers putting on a "meta" show.
PRESS TRIANGLE TO HIGH FIVE POSH SPACE KATNISS THE MILLION DOLLAR PRONS: Runner-Up for Best WoW Poster and Best Rant of 2012! WINNER OF RANTSAMANIA V!