"Success is not an accident."
Join Date: Jan 2007
Re: Champions League Mafia - Game Thread
^Lol I will never forget Imp's GOAT play of getting you, confirmed town, lynched over a fellow scum member.
I think most roles can be scum roles so I never confirm players off of their roles, unless it's a role that would only be given to town. The Duelist role can be a scum role as seen in AGOT. Magic was scum and had that role.
Skyfall's role is different since with a duelist, as has been said, you have to be a part of the duel whereas with Skyfall's role he didn't have to be a part of the match. The role seems townish but his play hasn't been pro-town. This doesn't mean he's scum since I don't know his meta. I want to know if his play thus far and in particular his misuse of his role is something he'd likely do as town. He should have saved that role to use later in the game where he'd have a much greater chance of making a match between scum. It isn't like he's someone who normally dies early in games so why use it this past day phase when your chances of making a town vs. town match are much higher than later in the game? And when I say play thus far, I mainly mean his behavior during the Kenny lynch. It striked me as off but since I don't know his meta I can't tell if his behavior there would be something he'd actually likely do as town. Some players seem more scummy when they're town than scum so I don't want to assume that because he behaved scummy there that means he's scum since I don't know his meta at all.
In terms of how his role would fit into the set-up, I could see Big_Man giving it to Skyfall's mafia, if he's mafia, as an extra kill. So instead of giving them like a poison kill, it comes in a different form and there's the advantage of being able to actually claim that role, like how Magic did in AGOT, and be seen as town because of that.
He needs to fully claim too.
Edit: Oops, excuse my double posting. When I checked initially it hadn't gone through but now it pops up twice.