I initially lynched Roger on Day 1 because my gut told me there was something off about his play. Then I helped push his lynch through after he claimed. I couldn't evaluate his claim using theme knowledge, but I did analyze his play and didn't like what I saw.
I'm not sure if I buy this claim. It doesn't make sense that he'd wait so long to claim if he's only a backup. I've heard of Princess Leia and I'm guessing she has a good role but if you're only the backup there's no danger in just claiming on day 1 given scum won't waste an early shot on you, esp. when you're Sterling. My vote for him had nothing to do with his performance in Christmas Mafia so him saying his refusal to claim was because he was being voted for that, I think only sXe had that reasoning, and being pissed seems like a cop out. I might be wrong but I think he should be lynched based on the way he handled the claim and the claim itself not holding up according to LC and McQueen.
Originally sXe was leading the wagon but then he jumped off. If you know my scum meta, I hate to buss and I wouldn't have pushed hard against Roger if I were scum with him. Looks like Obby bussed but he didn't actually make good points against Roger.
Roy no wait Rigor (1) - scrilla
Roger Sterling (15) - Titania, obby, MrMister, Fitz, Mclovin It, Showtime, x iCame2play x, LadyCroft, McQueen, Roy, sXe Maverick, chr1st0, Skyfall, Mikey Damage
sve Maverick (1) - DocBlue
obby (1) - Roger Sterling
LadyCroft (1) - Big_Man
scrilla (1) - MDP
Roger Sterling hammered, day coming up.
Then I pushed hard against Nov since after Mikey gave his results I felt he and Scrilla had to be scum. Keep in mind this is when many felt Scrilla was scum but Nov wasn't because they wouldn't protect two scum members which I thought was ridiculous reasoning. I think Nov could have got out of being killed since so many thought he was still town at the time if I hadn't pushed hard against him along with Dan and Chr1st0 who weren't fooled either.
Nov, I can't see scum protecting you on Night 1 instead of killing you. You're too good of a player and I think it's foolish role usage to use a scum protective role on a townie. That's basically wasting a protection that scum members want and need for themselves. Not many people were suspicious of Big Man on day 1 so they probably didn't think there was much of a risk in him being tracked or being caught with a role that could bring two scum down with him. I feel like you're reaching big time, here.
Are you bloody kidding me?
Scrilla has admitted to being scum. It was already evident before he admitted it upon Big Man's flip. Both Scrilla and Nov are scum. Big Man was their scum BG and could protect two mafia players. Mikey said that he had targeted Scrilla and Nov so they're both scum.
Here's Nov pushing against me because I wasn't going to let Mikey's results go and Nov had been accusing me earlier in the thread of being scum.
Read some of the thread and you will understand why it is quite possible I am town.. Your classic posts, falsely accusing everyone of being 100% scum with absolutely nothing to go by to make you think that, are cute. Proud of you though, you managed to keep it down to 2 this time, 1 of which is town, losing your touch or is this you playing conservative? I've said you are scum multiple times too, you pushing against me in retaliation only fits into your scum meta. Or anyones scum meta, due to it being scummy.
First of all, Nov, I haven't been accusing everyone of being 100% scum and those I have accused of that, Scrilla and you, wasn't based on absolutely nothing at all. It's actually the opposite. Let me repeat this, for what, the third time? Big Man was the scum BG. He could protect two players and based on Mikey's results we know he chose you and Scrilla. I don't see scum protecting such a strong town player as yourself on night 1 instead of just killing you. It's protection they would want for themselves. Scrilla has already flipped scum and I believe you're a scum tracker. It makes even more sense now given your claim why risk management was not practiced. You guys didn't think you had to worry about Big Man being tracked because you guys have the tracker. It makes perfect sense. And you claiming investigation-immunity on top of all this shows even more so that you are scum. No town player has any need to be investigation-immune.
Does every bloody thing need to be spelled out to you? Just because Big Man's role didn't say "Bodyguard" doesn't mean that isn't what he was. Common sense tells you he was the scum BG.
Obby also tried to turn the lynch on me the other day when he was on the line.
This is what I've done in the game. I've made mistakes too and thought Roy was 100% scum but I think most did and I missed several day phases in a row because of work but I did my best to make sure that whom I felt was scum was lynched.
I don't have anything showing why I'm not purple scum but I'm not and I think all that is left is the red GF since he hasn't flipped yet and there were only 3 kills last night rather than 4.