Thread Tools

**Red Viper** · 12-21-2012, 02:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SantaFitz

I think that's awful. Why would you want to play a game where you either have a 90% chance of winning or 10% chance of winning before the game even starts.

because it actually means something when you win as scum?

**Faraday** · 12-21-2012, 07:37 AM

but it should mean more to win as town?

scumhunting shouldn't be easy, that's why town wins should be slightly less common.

**TaylorFitz** · 12-21-2012, 10:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The MAGIC of Christmas

because it actually means something when you win as scum?

Yet it means nothing to win as town. So must of the time your would be meaningless. Making most games meaningless.

**IMPULSE** · 12-21-2012, 01:08 PM

magic should stop complaining taking away claims means you have to strip town of power roles for balance sakes. that will lower activity, these fake claims aren't scum keys to victory if they were we see at least a split of 60/14 in their favor, instead the win rate has balanced out.

we need a system that keeps track of how often someone is scum. some players are never scum and then there's me with 12/19 that shit is absurd when people can count how many times they've been scum on one hand for a year. i think i drew scum like 70% of the time in the last ten games and that shouldn't be possible.

**LadyCroft** · 12-21-2012, 02:20 PM

Best Overall Player - CP, Rush, Magic, HoL, Faraday

Best Town Player - Doc

Best Scum Player - CP, Fitz

Best Inidivual Performance in a Game - CP down 7 against 1 as scum and wins the game.

Worst Individual Performance in a Game - GA, WildWest

Ethan619 award for Worst Individual Performance in a Game - Me getting lynched on day one in Hunter Games while having a semi-power role.

The Hiplop award for Best Host - HoL

The Breakfast Cereal award for Best Game - Wild West, Death Note, GoT, Marvel

Best Mini Game - Homeland

The BkB Hulk award for Worst Host -

The Mike J Cab00se award for Worst Game - Transformers, only because Striker didn't have the time to do it properly. I liked the set-up though.

The Magic award for Most Dedicated - Shep, Magic, CP

The AussieFan award for Best 'Bannee' - I don't know what this is.

The Lawls award for future of mafia (best new player, had to have started after last years Christmas Mafia) - Fitz, Doc, Bigman

The DREAM TEAM award for Best Scum Group

The Alcoholic award for Most Underrated Player McQueen, chr1st0, Titania, Roy

The IMPULSE Award for Biggest Troll - GA

The Faraday award for Mr. Activity -

Best Manipulator -

Best Role Usage in a Game - CP as busdriver in my Public Enemies. Absolutely owned that game.

Best Post Restriction - CP as Rorshach and Me as the Lawyer Bear in Wildlife

**CamillePunk** · 12-21-2012, 02:24 PM

**TaylorFitz** · 12-21-2012, 03:29 PM

Lawyer beer was pretty great.

Also if there was a category for "Best Mini Mafia Scum Player" I would totally have that one. It's kind of amusing how often I'm scum in minis and how often I win as scum.

chr1st0 · 12-21-2012, 03:31 PM

I wonder what the win rate for scum in minis is? i can't think of a mini I was in that scum didn't win, although I can only think of 2

**Shepard** · 12-21-2012, 03:55 PM

I think winning as scum should feel better b/c it's harder to do and can be more of an individual thing but id probably rank better individual town games over better individual scum games. maybe thats just because i prefer scumhunting to being scum but w/e. id rather catch an entire scumteam than fool everyone for a p good scum win. plus as scum if you kill the cop n1 you pretty much win here

Quote:

Originally Posted by FaraCHRISTMASday

that was a nice plug lawls

he should've namedropped me since im doing a terrible job of replying to the pms he sends me about it

**Shepard** · 12-21-2012, 03:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by chr1st0

I wonder what the win rate for scum in minis is? i can't think of a mini I was in that scum didn't win, although I can only think of 2

town won kingmaker. after that my mini memory is crap. most i read definitely seem to end in scum wins. although idk how many just win via inactivity like we did in hydra

someone run another kingmaker whenever the section gets back to a point we can do minis side by side