[Red Viper]

I blame this on ch1st0. had he not protected roger of all people for no damn reason and allowed roger to die then town would have been far better off.

[Titania]

Originally Posted by Evolution

How can you not know who Frank Costanza is Anark? Losing respect for you right dere.

Also I'm not kidding I'll ban the next person who calles Tat "tit" or any variation of it. Whether you think you're funny and joking or not we've given enough warning for it and people still aren't getting it. Next person who says it goes I don't care.

Thank you for trying to get it to stop.

Originally Posted by MrMister

Just fucking ban whoever said it. Or tell me who did and I'll ban them.

Thank you for your help too.

I just don't want to be called that by anyone anymore. I don't even know if they're breaking the rules by doing it, I don't know what the rules are, but if they'll just stop w/o you guys having to ban anyone that would be great. I think I'd feel bad if they got banned. I hope it doesn't have to come to that for anyone.

Originally Posted by DocScrooge

How nobody followed my lynches when I fucking died as the hated townie is beyond me. I can't believe you critised me Sterling, you played so bad at the end I thought for sure you were scum. Anyways well played scum, I could have given town a chance if I hadn't been killed/repped back in

That was hilarious Doc! I held my breath when that next day phase began and hoped everything would go as planned and it did.
That's why we killed you and I'd never want someone I've intentionally killed because of their play, not their role, to replace right back in. Your play started getting hot, you threatened my teammates (I wasn't going to let you have Mikey and Roy) so you had to go.

Originally Posted by IMPULSE

i dropped a lot of hints all game long that only y'all can win and i was content with leading y'all to a win.

i then had a pm from dan reminding of my win condition and thought it would be shitty if i didn't make an effort to fulfill my win condition. that resulted in me gambling on anark's duel hoping he would chose you, roy would have been an okay choice.

i could have won w/ tat and mcqueen, but anark chose mcqueen, which made the game incredibly hard for me to win as i would have been left w/ tat and we would have gotten lynched.

i thought if couldn't win then my team deserve to win over town so i told them i would get anark lynched after explaining my actions.

I honestly had no idea you were a Usurper until you told us. Guess I was so focused on just coordinating night actions and scumhunting for a phantom indy group that didn't really exist, at least in the size I expected, and looking town that I didn't notice your hints in the QT. I remember feeling pissed when I saw you had done the Night without me, hadn't killed Anark, and then later I came back and saw my fear come true in him challenging one of us and you said it was hilarious. Tbf, I would have expected him to choose McQueen. All game long he was suspicious of McQueen for his inactivity. Not sure why you'd think he'd choose Mikey esp. since Mikey wasn't even posting since I told him to be scarce at that point.

Psst, next time we can buss the GF together.

Originally Posted by DocScrooge

Lol @OP mafia. If anything they were seriously underpowered IMO, in terms of numbers at least and town had so many powerful roles

Yeah, we definitely weren't overpowered. Town had like two cops and a bunch of other power roles. What killed you guys was the lack of crosskilling and the misuse of roles. We were darn lucky literally dodging all the bullets we had to dodge.

Originally Posted by IMPULSE

getting anark lynched was a surprise to me. i thought roger had mentioned a framer earlier so i was going to use that as the basis of my case, but he didn't. at the point i was going to leave the game and come back the next day, but i already said i would get him lynched to make up for my usurper gamble backfiring so i looked through his posts and threw a case together.

thankfully the last three deaths, the hated townie being killed, the duelist role, roy and damages claim, his role selection and his cop dispute where he questioned the credibility, and sterling's faulty results lead to something that could get them some votes.

i could have tried to win with tat but i didn't see it happening and i wouldn't have been motivated to try for that much longer.

You getting confirmed town lynched was GOAT play Imp! That was unbelievable to me. When I saw that Anark had challenged McQueen I felt sick because I wanted to win with 5 of us that day and knew that now everything would change. Thank you for your effort esp. since it wasn't really even your battle! I don't know if you see this as a victory or not for yourself but I definitely view you as a winner and I really enjoyed having you and Roy to bounce ideas off in the QT.

Originally Posted by dancer the mareindeer

Scum played great, especially Titania and IMPULSE even if he technically didn't win... Town had a lot of bad luck like I said with power roles asking to be replaced. Anark (I think it was him) played pretty good, he actually made a post early in the game where he picked out basically every mafia member, just nothing ever came of that.



True. Though Frank Costanza is a decent stand-in.


Satan could've won as well, I think if Anark hadn't used his role Mikey could've just been bussed and then go for Roger the next day. Though getting Anark lynched was impressive. Actually I thought the Framer as the Usurper would go around behind their backs and frame the godfather just as another idea.

Thank you for the game, Dan! You're such a great host and so generous with your time to host Christmas mafia again this year. After hosting my own game I know how much work goes into preparing a game, esp. a game of this size, and then modding it so I really appreciate your effort. I enjoyed it.

Originally Posted by TaylorFitz

Good game Dan.

And town should have listened town should have listened to my fake info on Tat.

I laughed when Lawls and Ziggler flipped town and you lost all credibility. You need to stop faking info. I sensed you were faking info. on me. If you start to fake info. on your way out then you'll get killed earlier in games.

Originally Posted by Showtime

I blame this on ch1st0. had he not protected roger of all people for no damn reason and allowed roger to die then town would have been far better off.

chr1st0 probably thought he had a strong investigative role so I wouldn't blame him. If you think about it this all goes back to Lawls again. He basically saved me twice. We couldn't have done it without you, Lawls. He was like our 8th member, lol.

[Red Viper]

doc no one followed your reads because you were awful 80% of the game. never lynch anyone over the sk.

[Skyfall]

I didn't see Tat as scum for a second. If anything, showtime attacking her made me think she was even more town. Also, Fitz, did you kill postage?

[Titania]

That logic of his frustrated me to no end in the QT. I understood it but just hated his favortism of them. He was so adamant in wanting the Indy's to win over us that it was frustrating and I knew we'd have a hard time winning with Doc around just because of that.

I was convinced Doc was scum until the role reveal and even after that I truly had a hard time accepting he was town because his play had been so scummy and I expected the Indy group to be bigger and not another SK on top of them. The set-up caught me off guard but I liked Dan's creativity with the game.

@ Skyfall
I don't think Magic attacked me in this game and I thought you might have been Taylor's partner since your claim seemed so convenient.

[Nov]

Just for everyones information I pinpointed nearly every one of the non-townies.

[McQueen]

Yeah your list was pretty good Nov.

[Titania]

Yeah, your reads were spot on, Nov. That's why you had to go. We were in luck when you turned out to be the BG.

[McQueen]

Titania when and where do you want to continue our fight?

[Alcoholic]

A scum actor. Ice cold, dan the marino, ICE COLD!