Originally Posted by Merry Mikey Damage
How does that confirm him as town? He just received the protection. It's not like he can accept/reject it. That confirms nothing, and he can be just easily scum as he is town.
If Roger flips scum, Tat you just made yourself very suspicious.
I didn't say that if Roger told us that he had received the protection from Chr1st0 that it would confirm him as town. What I want to know is how Roger survived the lynch from the other day. Him surviving that lynch has made me most suspicious of him because I would think if he were town and had received Chr1st0's protection then he would have just told us that. But instead he keeps ignoring the question. I don't see what he's worried about by sharing that info. since even if scum faked counter claimed him then he would get lynched, we'd see he's town, then we'd lynch the player who counter claimed him. A one for one trade would be worth it esp. since we haven't gotten one mafia player yet. The protown move would be to say that yes, he survived that lynch because he received Chr1st0's protection. So him not coming out and saying that makes me think it's because he didn't receive the protection but was lawyered by his scum team. Like maybe he knew it would be a gambit trying to get Magic lynched that day so the night before they lawyered him. Though I'd think by now if Sterling wasn't the one protected by Chr1st0's role then whoever was would have owned up to it.
I wonder if the person doesn't get told that they were the chosen one and I wish Roger would explain to me what he was trying to do in getting Magic to claim. It didn't make sense. I'm not sure if Roger would be that bold to go after a town Magic though. There's no way he'd be able to lynch Magic without solid info., but maybe he was naive.