Originally Posted by Merry Mikey Damage
so the gist is that Roger saw that a BG was on Magic night one, and tried to exploit whether it was a townie BG or a scum BG?
heh. makes sense to me, I suppose. Not sure I see much advantage to doing this if he was scum.
The advantage is that it explains his play with regards to the Magic situation. The other possibility is that he tried to get Magic mislynched, knowing he could explain it away by saying he thought 'no results' meant that Magic was the GF or something, of course not knowing at the time that Mikey's role would make him scum if he was known to have failed with his attempt to target Magic. St Nick offered him an out and he took it since there wasn't any other explanation.
Originally Posted by Roger Sterling
After I saw purifier flip, I thought the BG was more likely to be scum too.
Why? The Purifier protected against non-killing roles. I'll be amazed if we don't have a BG in a game this huge. I am struggling to believe you but you'll either be killed or caught in a lie eventually since you have to give results each Night now. If you miss another Night phase though i'll probably lynch you on principle.
I am not sold on rogers claim I want to see what others think now and also evolution you should claiming enough of this I have strong feel both roger and evolution are mafia
I really don't like this post. Rising picks the two main wagons of Day and seems to be pursuing more aggressively than I can recall from him.
Lawls ? well did scrilla say anything about his role usage on night 2? and evo claim is believable and provable aswell I guess
Scrilla said the only players he blocked had already died. If Lawls flips scum this post is gonna look like you're making up excuses for him.
Pretty sure Evo is town based on his claim but his claim incriminates Lawls so i'd like to hear from the future.
Originally Posted by ST. KAEPERNICK
I buy Sterling's reasoning
I'd have done the same thing, Magic is NOT a night 1 town BG target, their are better options out there.
Why are people saying this? Magic is definitely a potential Night 1 town BG target. He's one of the best players in the section. Who would you put above him out of the players in this game? Rush possibly? That's about it.
what in the fucking world is nov thinking by asking the GF to come out? that's pure stupidity. step your game up, nov. if you do that you fuck the bodyguard over, as we have no blocker and you force him to self protect, which might not work considering scum could have a blocker.
so you get a situation where the guard is in jeopardy unless he has a watcher and even if we do that then scum is free to kill any player of their choosing. think before you speak.
don't get why people were questioning skyfall and why he claimed it fits into town him, he also doesn't think through anyway, but after shooting himself in the foot as scum and getting scolded for it he would be a lot more careful. i don't get why people use their forensics roles on stupid kills.
I think I pinted it out a few games back. I can't believe how often Forensic Investigator has been wasted lately. Such a powerful role. These new kids need to learn how to use it.
I want Lawls to explain how Evo is still alive right now