Better late than never for the suspicion list. Just copied and pasted from a notepad file on my laptop, so the thoughts written are more for my own benefit and reading, so some of it may not make sense or may seem wrong to some of you. Been updating it as the game has gone on.
town:
skyfall (
pr, scumhunting)
big-man (put neck out for lawls day 1, definitely wouldnt do so if scum)
doddsy (against magic wagon, would just bandwagon as scum)
jigsaw (post about josh confirming his innocence looks town, not out of the woods though as i thought he was scum originally as he seemed to be looking for any lynch by flip flopping heaps)
magic (major variant, playing townish)
lawls (claimed busdriver, terrible play can be excused cos its lawls)
sXe (scumhunting and putting in effort instead of flying under radar as he usually does as scum, same thoughts as me)
clover (bad player so scumminess can be excused, seems to be trying to scumhunt, wouldnt do so as scum)fitz (pushing too hard on magic to be scum, using good logic, pro town, good scum player though so cant be trusted)
docscrooge (same thoughts as me, scumhunting alot, some strange posts but willing to overlook them)
ziggler (replaced in, was against the magic wagon)
mcqueen/belt buckle (
pr)
hohohovolution (pushed too hard on lawls to be scum, scumhunting, + too many jumped on him)
mikey (replaced in, claimed beloved townie)
anark (scumhunting, big town tell for him i think)
josh (replaced in)
mdp (claimed double voter, always inactive so not sus for that)
jupes (little bit of scumhunting as of late, pushing on rising, posted fluff mostly though, dont know him at all)
scum:
scrilla (done nothing at all, said he would read back and give thoughts but didnt, inactive/flying under the radar)
tkok (sheeping, doing nothing else, trying to look helpful, inactive/flying under the radar)
titania (unusually inactive, blaming it on life, bad points when scumhunting (though this is a common occurence), attempting to force suspicion on anyone for no reason)
roy (dont know him at all, posting a lot but most irrelevant, bad points when he does scumhunt)
???:
kenny (sheeping a lot, posting a lot and trying to look helpful without offering all that much substance, defending sxe though)
croft (unusually inactive + not scumhunting as much as usual, though posted about having reasons for something which seemed townish + iffy of magic wagon)
alcoholic (strangely hasnt scumhunted at all, strangely inactive, strongly against magic wagon though)
kaepernick (dont know him at all, posting fluff, not scumhunting at all, did publicly write off day 1 though which is townish)
rush (defended magic hard, iffy besides that, not having his usual influence)
rising (always hard to read him, could be scum just because no one else appears to be, did push hard on magic which can go either way)
impulse (no idea, can't read into any of his posts either as he loves to bus)
roger (obvious)
I'll
vote scrilla as he has the most votes of my main suspects.
Christmas Mafia 2012 Gameplay Thread
Re: Christmas Mafia 2012 Gameplay Thread
