[Jupe Skywalker]

Triple post

[DocBlue]

Originally Posted by Anark

I had explained it during the previous night phase. I've played with him before when he's been quite active as town, but I don't play all that much so maybe I'm wrong.

One I'm not wrong about is McQueen. He usually loves the banter.

If Doc and others can confirm that MDP is usually inactive regardless of alignment, then I'll probably switch to McQueen, as I'm sure he is definitely usually more active.

I know it's not the best reasoning, but it's also been true in my experience that at least some scum will always try and fly under the radar.

Meh you shouldn't take our word for it, we could just as esily be his scumbuddies anyways. I never even attempt to read MDP but yeah he seems to fly under the radar regardless of alignment, perhaps others are better at picking up any subtleties in his play though.

Originally Posted by The MAGIC of Christmas

he's not.

neither is MDP.

scrilla is a good vote as he said he would read back and provide thoughts and yet never did(obviously). he has done literally nothing and probably is scum.


did CP actually say something that cleared roger? from what I remember from last night he really didn't clear him in any way.

also I don't ever remember interacting with you past day 1, tat, but i've been in a mind fuck lately so that shouldn't be surprising. my last exam is today.

Good luck with the exam. Nah CP didn't clear Roger I don't think? I don't know how he could since Roger didn't claim to visit him? But as Evo says a vote for Roger is wasted since he's invincible for at least one more phase. He still hasn't cleared up his info though and he really should. I still think he's probably town so don't really care if he doesn't say what the info is but an indication of what your claim means with respect to his info would be nice

[DocBlue]

LC=Evo. How the fuck did I make that mistake

[Titania]

Originally Posted by ST. KAEPERNICK

No will was posted, so no, he did not give anything, and he was either role blocked and killed, or strong man killed, since otherwise he'd be kill immune.

I'm thinking since he was so inactive he just didn't use his role at all which bloody sucks. The write-up doesn't hint that he was strong-manned and I don't see scum strong-man killing him to begin with. He didn't pose a threat. Maybe he had to choose one or the other and he probably didn't choose either because he wasn't active.

Originally Posted by Merry Mikey Damage

You think Magic is scum after he proved his role?

There is no way that magic's role is non-town. Not unless Dan is a bastard.

The role makes me think he's town but I think there's still always the possibility of Magic being scum. Like you should never ever think this guy is town unless he's been mod-confirmed. I don't understand how he can think Evo is actually town unless he's scum with him. Though he's been high and focused on exams so that could be why Evo has fooled him.

Originally Posted by Big_Man

Vote: Mikey

I want to hear from him asap.

Originally Posted by Anark

I was spring-cleaning underneath the radar (I'm actually late, not early) and look what I found, an entire MDP just gathering dust. Let's give it a brush down and see what condition it's in. Out you come.

Vote MDP

Big Man, Anark, and everyone else, please don't make posts like these which can easily be interpreted as info-based. If Mikey really is our Beloved Townie, then he was outed for no reason.

Vote Evolution
I can't see him being town, not with the way he's played.

[Cloverleaf]

Originally Posted by DocScrooge

You're wobbling all over the place up on top of that fence. I'm not a big fan of indecision in mafia, it comes off as scum unwilling to put themselves out there.

The timing of this vote irks me. You weren't really going for the lynch on Magic so hard until a little pressure started being placed on you, then you seemed to go for it before going to sleep once a few more votes on you had accumulated.

I don't like how you insulted Dan in this instance. Just seems like overkill to sell your frustrations. Who did you rep in for again?

Vote LC

Happiest with this atm

The reasons i've highlighted the above will become apparent.

Originally Posted by DocScrooge

Anark can be Town although ftr i've been scumhunting as much as possible considering I get about 3/4 hours to myself when I finish work and most of that is spent on non-mafia related things. Your post did make me realise just how few players are actually doing anything in this game though. We could genuinely go the entire game with no lynch ever occurring, especially since we're already down 5 townies, plus there are numerous inactives.

Vote Scrilla

Originally Posted by DocScrooge

If you want a reason just take a look at his posts. Pretty self explanatory

Ok, So Docs puts his vote on Scrilla. Fair enpugh, he gives his reasons. I agree with them Scrilla's lack of interest in the game so far could be that he doesn't car cause he knows a lot more than he's letting on

Originally Posted by Big_Man

Vote: Mikey

I want to hear from him asap.

This is all Mikey says...

Originally Posted by DocScrooge

Unvote. Vote Mikey

Straight on it, literally straight away.

Originally Posted by DocScrooge

I don't think anyone would be stupid enough to fake info now. It's probably worth lynching MDP if Anark is as sure as I think he might be but we should probably see if Big has caught Mikey first since that sounds pretty solid too and i'd rather Big didn't potentially die with his info. Lawls and Sterling still have some explaining to do also

Originally Posted by Big_Man

FUCK.

I realise that was my fault but I thought people would realise I was just copying this post. I don't even know why I just did that.

Is that the role where the next day phase is skipped when you die?

Big Man says this...

Originally Posted by DocScrooge

Holy fuck. We seriously just outed the Beloved townie as a joke? I legit give up

Unvote

Doc off the wagon in a flash.

Originally Posted by Big_Man

May I ask how you know for sure he's the beloved townie?

Big man might be on to him, I dunno...whatever

Originally Posted by DocScrooge

Vote MDP

If this comes to nothing i'm never following 'info' again

Whoa, straight on the MDP wagon, based on what exactly.

Originally Posted by Anark

Whoa. I never said I had info, if you're talking about my vote for MDP. I don't have anything on anybody.

I'm voting for him because his lack of activity this far into the game screams scum to me. I've played as scum with him and it's not an accident.

I guess he was just voting for the same reasons Doc put his vote on Scrilla in the first place.

Originally Posted by DocScrooge

Oh. MDP is never active.

Unvote. Vote Scrilla I'm just going to stick to my guns from now on. Fuck all your reads and fuck info

Oh, there you go, back to square one.

Originally Posted by DocScrooge

Meh you shouldn't take our word for it, we could just as esily be his scumbuddies anyways. I never even attempt to read MDP but yeah he seems to fly under the radar regardless of alignment, perhaps others are better at picking up any subtleties in his play though.

Admits no attempt to read MDP but was willing to put a vote vote on...based on what exactly?

Vote Doc

I want MVPJUPES to tell me if I'm doing the right thing?

[DocBlue]

That's great. Do you know what it is to think someone had info? It's not like they were obviously not hinting at info or anything. Big accepted that he made a mistake, I don't see how me following Big's info was suss, I explained I didn't think anyone would fake info so I thought Big's info was legit. He wasn't faking but he was joking, how was I honestly to know that? I also thought Anark was hinting at info which was pretty obvious, as soon as I saw that wasn't the case I went back to my original vote.
For the record none of what you quoted has me in any way sitting on a fence. If anything i'm repeatedly jumping either side of the fence

[LadyCroft]

I'm with Doc on this one. I get shit for doing the same thing in games where I assume someone has info and I vote them. I don't think someone should explicitly say they have info. Why out your role? If someone hints at it I'll take their word for it for the time being unless I already have reason to believe the contrary.

[DocBlue]

The other point about scum being afraid to put themselves out there doesn't apply to me at all either. Some of your points are legit retarded. Big admits he was joking with his info, so I was supposed to stay on the wagon? Or would you prefer I waited an hour before jumping off the wagon, because that would somehow be less suspicious? I don't get at all what you're getting at with that point.
My reasons for voting Scrilla aren't based on low levels of activity either so my reasoning isn't at all the same as Anark's for voting MDP. I said to read his posts which I invite you to do and it's pretty clear why I think he's scum.
I already told you why I placed my vote on MDP.

[WOOLCUNT]

Vote:scrilla

Says he will read back, then doesn't. also a lot of his post seem to be nonsense.

[WHINY CUNT]

Originally Posted by Not-Jupes

You must be new to Mafia. let me introduce myself. i'm DR JUPES, the best player that has ever played mafia. last year xmas mafia

Join Date: Feb 2012