Only quickly skimmed through the thread, see a lot of people blaming Magic's play. Pretty funny tbh. Using his role to switch the lynch from himself to Roger was poor, but apart from that the general play of town is laughably bad. Anyone questioned Roger on his info? b/c if you used your brain, there was no role he could have that would need Magic to claim further than 'i have no night role'. But of course you have morons saying 'Magic isn't getting away with not claiming' 'roger has info' etc etc.
Here's an idea, how about instead of following like mindless little sheep, you actually use some common sense and some deductive reasoning for a change. Mafia isn't a hard game but the follow the cop stratedgy is used every fucking game and its pathetic. Here, i'll go through it step by step again;
1) Roger claims info, wants a claim
Okay, asking for a claim when you supposedly have info indicates that you either aren't a cop, or are trying to be coy about it. So this almost rules out some roles that Roger could be.
2) Magic says bullshit on results, he has no night role
Now Roger didn't say Magic was lying about that. He quoted Fitz saying he had weak info. So this then rules out any tracking results, gunsmith results, and you can probably rule out role cop at this point as well (seeing as roger really wouldn't need a claim if he knew Magic's role.
Now the question you ask yourself at this point, what possible role could Roger have that would get info and couldn't tell Magic's alignment?
The only remotely logical answer was colour cop, provided by Big Man. In that case Roger is a moron for asking for a claim of the role over a claim on colour