Originally Posted by DocBlue
If I ever bother to do another game I think i'll ban people from saying WIFOM, OMGUS and tunneling. It's not tunneling when you're one of many players I have publicly stated could be scum.
And if she dies toNight anyway because scum know she blocked them? Not to mention it could just wind up confusing us further unless Tat survives, her Roleblock goes through and both the SK and scum's kills go through. Considering Kenny should be getting protection then Tat is dead toNight if she hit scum/if she's Town.
I just re-read that and it doesn't seem very clear. My point is that Tat blocking the same player won't really tell us anything, unless she hit the SK although I think the SK killed LC anyway. I think it's worth hearing her target but I appear to be alone on that one. There's also my other point that surely she picked someone scummy and yet we're letting it go?
if she dies tonight then it doesn't matter who she blocked. i know you like opposing, but don't it just for the sake of being opposite of me.
nothing in mafia is clear but a cop result.
i want her to block the same person if she thinks she blocked the killer for very simple reasons. if it's vigilante or serial killer then she's golden with her blocking and has to make a judgment call.
here's the thing if it's mafia they will switch the killer at which point tat will most likely release the name. she obviously didn't feel comfortable releasing it during this phase and if she can rule out the possibility of it being the vigilante then she's more likely to give us the name.
the fact that no one has claimed they were blocked could be a possible hint to be a killing role.
tat is a hesitant player so she wouldn't release something unless she was confident in it, which is why blocking the same person twice is better than any other option.