i really wanted to be wagoned and have to claim PGO for the reactions alone. it would have been hilarious.
Yeah, it would have been! When I first started working on this game, many months ago, you were in that phase where you'd claim PGO every game so I thought it'd be fun for you to be able to claim PGO and for it to be true for once.
Great game, tat.
Nothing personal to anyone I went off on in the QT.
Just in good fun.
Except you, imp. You whore.
You played really well, Mikey! If you guys had been luckier with your kill targets and the purple team hadn't role revealed you twice then it could have been a Volturi victory.
if he wasn't the bomb doc probably would have shot him
All the BP/NK-Immune players could shoot the bomb without dying.
Originally Posted by dan the marino
Great game, thanks. Town was a bit oped though. I know there were two big scum groups but nexus, pgo, bp vigilante, unlynchable bomb, all with a legend meant it was a bit impossible for us to win towards the end there.
I still had a lot of fun though, thanks for hosting. And congrats to town and Mikey for making it that far. It ended up being a relatively close game.
It's like I threw in every power role I could think of!
In hindsight I should have given the Godfather and Godmother the strong-man kills. I gave town the BP roles, 1-shot High Priest and Legend to make sure Town wasn't wiped out because since the scum to town ratio was 13 to 15 at the start of the game, where it could have been 14 to 15 if the Rebels had successfully recruited a Town player on Night 1, without crosskilling Town would have easily been outnumbered early. Plus all non-town factions had their share of roles too. Like the manipulative roles--Redirector and Traffic Controller (Reverse Busdriver)--could have easily screwed with three strong town roles. If either group had found the Vig with MDP or Shep still alive then that would have meant an extra kill. Your QT work was clutch on Night 1 when Shep chose to traffic control you and Scrilla but you had him roleblocked. I felt roleblocking should take precedence.
Oh. A bit disappointed that roles weren't randomised. I mean town roleblocker is my favourite role pretty much but I think it sets a bad precedent. Not least because people will be trying to outguess you in your future games, now. And that's not really playing mafia.
I'll randomize roles next time. I just wanted to have some fun with my first game and also I didn't want to chance randomization messing up my game since my set-up was delicate. And I wasn't aware that town roleblocker was your favorite role. I just didn't want to give you or Rush BP roles or really powerful roles because I thought that'd be unfair to non-town. I'd probably never hear the end of it.
*shrug* overall he played well. the fact is if there had been another sk it was obviously him? the whole spiel about killing both teams wasn't needed.
I'm not sure about the set-up in terms of balance.
Town have small numbers but super powerful roles, but they could still get fucked over by a lack of crosskills. I think cutting down on the scum and giving town some more weak roles/vt's might have been a better option.
The actual fakeclaims, the way the game was modded and everything else was perfect. Very impressed in that regard. Roles should be randomised though.
Yeah, it was a risky set-up where it could have been pretty one-sided if night action choices had been different plus I didn't like how almost everything came down to role info. Definitely doing things differently next time around. I learned a lot from modding this game.
tat didn't randomize roles and yet shepard wasn't my sk partner(pez was fine, but with shep we couldn't have failed
should have just remade the original AGOT team tbh, well without flashflood of course.
Pez was one of the players who inspired me to create the Twilight Haters faction so of course I needed to make him a part of it. I don't remember the orignial AGOT team, lol.
roles not being randomised and me not getting one of the ton of nk immune roles is annoying. I should always be a PGO. Would fuck up people night 1 every game.
PGO suited Imp more than you. Come on, you know this. I wanted to see you do wonders with your Alert Townie role.
i got the bodyguard though
Actually, LC had originally chosen to protect Faraday on night 1 but then changed it to you because she thought he might be a part of a cult.
So I got Legend because I made(randomly) Titania SK with a good Fake Claim in Samurai Jack?
Lol Yeah and you're a player who normally isn't killed off early. I would have been in TEARS if my Legend had died on Night 1.
Tat made me BP Vig. I must be her favourite
With the set-up Town needed to have an awesome Vig so I thought you'd be perfect. From what you had said before I put up sign-ups, I knew you'd put in effort for this game and from what you've said about Vigs in the past I knew you'd be responsible with the role. Also, you weren't likely to be targeted early game by the manipulative roles as guys like Faraday and Rush would.
Also Shep I was hurt you didn't try to recruit me. Would have seriously considered it although maybe not if I lost my role. Can see why you wouldn't though...
If they had recruited you and you had accepted the Town would have been SCREWED.
I'm glad that didn't happen. That's a reason the recruit would lose their role if they accepted since Town needed their power roles.