why didn't you try your random list thing? In the last three games(2 as town and one as scum) you did it both times as town and not as scum. are you scum? Did I just catch you? Was it really that simple?
I didn't do the random list thing because it hasn't helped me in the two games I did it in. Probably because it's just based on luck. I found last game that it ended up distracting me because I started trying to make my reads match the list, though it was more at a unconscious level, yet that made my reads become bias.