Why did Doc have to replace you in? And no, I didn't kill you this time.
If you look at every one of my past games as scum you'll see it's never happened. It pays to pay attention to patterns. They are relevant. If more people realized that Day 1 lynches are normally on townies than scum than we wouldn't have so many mislynches on Day 1.
you're right, we should nothing on day 1. What separates a good player from an average player/bad player is that they realize that wagons in the beginning are important. you get reads off of them, even if you're pressuring a person that isn't scum.
and just because it never happened before doesn't mean it will never happen. I was never lynched as town before but that still happened.