Originally Posted by Titania
What was my contradiction? I don't think I contradicted myself.
Why? I can see the third Power Puff Girl being a fake claim but at the same time I think he could be telling the truth. I think he is the Vengeful Townie though of course I could be wrong since I can't read him. More players need to give their input regarding him.
people find a contradiction in you wanting mafia lynched on day one, noting how rare of an occurrence it is, when you wouldn't claim day one. players feel like claiming and lynching goes hand in hand and in the scenario you stated one doesn't happen w/o the other.
in short the precedent you set in this game contrasts with your wish. the discussion is fruitless as it rehashes day one, but doesn't touch on anything new. it forces you to explain the contradiction, which is a transition into WIFOM.
we're left with a circular discussion, which is fancy illusion of sitting on our hands. we get nothing out of your explanation, we're not lynching you b/c of said contradiction and we don't learn anything new out of it. most of night two has been extravagant fluff.