To the person who laughed when I said four...
Mr. Lawls, sXe, STUFF, and Rawlin.
This game is very simple. If you have a role and use it well, you could pick out scum. If scum fucks up in the thread and you call them out on it, you could pick out scum. There is no other possible way to pick out scum. If there is, then please tell me. I've place this game now for over a year, and with each game, I've tried to get better and better. Yes, I did accuse a lot of people of being non-town...but guess what, I was right with each one. The only thing that ticks me off is that because my username is not "Lostfap" or "Postage" or maybe even "STUFF" that people won't give two shits about who I call out, unless I obviously said, "I know for a fact that __ is scum because of last night."
What is town supposed to do when the investigator/watcher/etc. are all dead and the mafia try really hard to not fuck up and to cause a no-lynch? Take gambles by having people who observe, no? I keep repeating myself, but DH's game I knew who mafia was (I was mole) and was observing how mafia players behave and post. Meaningless posts like, "Oh, let me read the past few posts to catch up." Why do you have to post that? Just read it and then post. They post that because they want activity so they don't get replaced and because they just wanna show that they're trying to take initiative and try to lead town.
Call me a stupid, terrible player all you want, but I called out four correct non-townies. I had no role, so I didn't have much to work with.
K, sorry, rant is over.
Edit - I'm next in line to be replaced