Thread Tools

**IMPULSE** · 12-08-2012, 06:10 PM

the room had 20 players. that isn't a mini so it counts. fuck what dan says.

shut up. winning percentages don't make you scum player of the year. if we did things by win percentages dan marino would be the greatest player of all time, especially as scum.

**Shepard** · 12-08-2012, 06:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Big_Man

You played well while you were alive but iirc your fake claim was bad because it didn't explain why you didn't die (or maybe I just didn't get the role)

Plus you weren't alive towards end game where we had to take out a 3rd party who were on the verge of winning without anyone knowing they existed.

well i was riding on taylor saying he protected me but that never happened

also im never exactly super srs when i brag about this its just b/c magic always berates me for being awful at scum and i PROVED HIM WRONG

**Magic** · 12-08-2012, 06:16 PM

the way I win is better than the way you win.

**Shepard** · 12-08-2012, 06:21 PM

your best win was when we WON TOGETHER tho in GOT

**dan the marino** · 12-08-2012, 06:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Seven Sheps a-swimming

i think people voted for christmas mafia in last years awards, so we'll leave nominations open till after then

I'd have to check back but I'm pretty sure it wasn't counted, otherwise that scum team would've won GOAT.

Quote:

Originally Posted by IMPULSE

the room had 20 players. that isn't a mini so it counts. fuck what dan says.

shut up. winning percentages don't make you scum player of the year. if we did things by win percentages dan marino would be the greatest player of all time, especially as scum.

**Magic** · 12-08-2012, 06:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Seven Sheps a-swimming

your best win was when we WON TOGETHER tho in GOT

I caused that win. without me it was hopeless.

where's pez?

**Titania** · 12-08-2012, 06:42 PM

Big Man is the reason we won Jobbers since it came down to Evo or me being lynched towards the end, which was the lynch that basically decided whether mafia or the Indy group would win since Town would have been able to easily link Big Man to me once I flipped and I think at that point no one even knew that the Indy group existed. Big Man gave a convincing enough argument so MDP broke the tie and lynched Evo. Though of course we did it all for our Godfather, Shep.

I think Magic is the best scum player in this section. It is the way he wins, as Town leader, that makes it impressive.

**Shepard** · 12-08-2012, 06:44 PM

didnt his power get fucked by sandy? other than that i'd guess he's probably been busy w/ work. i miss pez

Quote:

Originally Posted by dancer the mareindeer

I'd have to check back but I'm pretty sure it wasn't counted, otherwise that scum team would've won GOAT.

i just had a look and best scum group was one of the nominations and christmas mafia got a load for that, then DHOOPER took them out of the official things.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Titania

Though of course we did it all for our Godfather, Shep

THANK YOU

**Magic** · 12-08-2012, 06:46 PM

tat if you dont vote me best for everything im going to be more mad than I was in nfl mafia. after all that I expect a vote from you.

and im glad you seem to be the only one that realizes that the way I win as scum is harder than the way imp/taylor do. I dont cost at all, and I usually end up with the most posts as well as causing town to mislynch a lot.

**Titania** · 12-08-2012, 06:56 PM

I honestly think you're the best player in the section, MAGIC. I think it's probably that, the way you win as scum, that has me paranoid about you. Don't want to be OWNED like that. If you weren't so condescending at times, I think I'd be less paranoid and wouldn't be such a pain in the ass for you.