The thing you say about role pm's. From when I started playing I think all the games I've played in had no lynches on day 1, so I was never in a game where there was a lynch on day 1. I'm too lazy to read past games so on the day 1's where there were lynches what did you guys base it on?
Very little, I'm just simply stating that trying to identify the mafia by win conditions is somewhat unfair, take prison break for example where I had to guess being inmate aligned(I'm super not everyone else would be). Stuff like that.
The first day's potential lynch in Mushroom Kingdom was based on something, people playing suspiciously.