Thread Tools

**.BD** · 09-27-2008, 04:21 AM

Yeah, Postage kind of implied that he wasn't in his posts I felt.

Unlynch Jigsaw

And Sticksy not really any justification

Lets just see how things play out.

Lynch don corleone

I want to see if anyone agrees with me, I have been thinking this for a while.

**Rush** · 09-27-2008, 04:23 AM

I didn't really want any justification seeing as i know you're pulling stuff out your ass atm

**Hohenheim of Light** · 09-27-2008, 04:30 AM

Don Corleone is always sus, even when he's not playing mafia

And yeah, JiGSaW is probably innocent but that hasn't stopped anybody else from lynching him. I only lynched him so that we can move on with the game, without being stuck in the most awkward phase of the game, DAY 1

**Fail** · 09-27-2008, 04:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ownage™

Your rating went up so you're the punk.

Unlynch

Lynch Jigsaw

I don't think he's mafia but it seems inevitable.

If you're 90% sure he is innocent, then why are you lynching him?

**Nov** · 09-27-2008, 04:33 AM

Lynch: JiGSaW Why not?

Anyway I find both Fail and BD a bit sus, but only one of them can be scum as BD stated that Fail was his primary suspicion.

**Fail** · 09-27-2008, 04:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nov

Lynch: JiGSaW Why not?

Anyway I find both Fail and BD a bit sus, but only one of them can be scum as BD stated that Fail was his primary suspicion.

sigh..

Have you even read the last few posts?

**Rush** · 09-27-2008, 04:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nov

Lynch: JiGSaW Why not?

Anyway I find both Fail and BD a bit sus, but only one of them can be scum as BD stated that Fail was his primary suspicion.

Okay if majority hasn't already been reached Lynch: Nov

And may i remind people that mafia can fake attacks and arguments on each other, it happens all the fucking time you dunces.

**Hohenheim of Light** · 09-27-2008, 04:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fail

If you're 90% sure he is innocent, then why are you lynching him?

Okay, here goes

Lynching JiGSaW is inevitable. I didn't want to do it either but even if I don't, majority will be reached for sure. If he turns out mafia, then people would suspect those who didn't lynch him, which forces the smarter innocents (Those who didn't bandwagon) into a position that they can't defend themselves because let's face it, it was JiGSaW and the real mafia would most likely have lynched him just when the noticed he was going down, which was from the get go. Most people won't think so much though

On the other hand, if he turns out innocent, no big loss because he's not the kind of player that you would preserve till the end of the game and the mafia will have bagged him

Therefore, everyone has a reason to lynch him even if the reasons are all kind of stupid

**Fail** · 09-27-2008, 04:41 AM

And what if he turns up innocent with a powerful innocent role, like Legend or Investigator?

Then we truly fucked up because of some peoples stupid decision making, when we had the opportunity to change it to someone else. I don't care, I don't expect to be around long.

Lynch Jigsaw

**Rush** · 09-27-2008, 04:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Invincible

On the other hand, if he turns out innocent, no big loss because he's not the kind of player that you would preserve till the end of the game and the mafia will have bagged him

Therefore, everyone has a reason to lynch him even if the reasons are all kind of stupid

If we keep him around then it will force the mafia to kill him thereby wasting a kill. Also what if he has a good role? Is that no big loss?