Well, when I'm mafia, I usually pick someone who is a strong player, and when they are inevitably getting lynched, will strongly defend them. I think that's what you were trying to do, only Fail came up as individual. I also believe that it's possible Invincible and Sticksy were doing the same.
It sucks our investigator already, died. Hopefully we have a legend.
I didn't defend Fail, i was against him. I did defend Jigsaw strongly but he's not someone who i would call a "strong player"