Actually now going to do a little write up on my LEAST favorite monthly shows that TNA has done
Destination X 2005
Sheesh, what cannot be said about this show. Outside of the Ultimate X match, this show had nothing but shit on it. Phi Delta Slam/Harris Bros AND Trytan/Monty Brown on one show with one of the worst heel turns that the company did? Oi ve
None! Just about every show that year was at least solid. Some had some questionable stuff (I'm looking at you, No Surrender 06) but nothing that made shows unbearable.
Against All Odds 2007
2007. My least favorite year for the company. As TripleG said above, this show was pretty weak. The Prison Yard match was solid, and the main event was as well despite the overbooked ending. However, one of TNA's worst matches ever that goes forgotten now a days was the Tuxedo Match.
Destination X 2007
This show had a great main event in Christian/Samoa Joe. Everything else show was quite bad. Steiner/Angle was one of Angle's worst PPV encounters in TNA. The double-bullrope match. BG James & Kip James/Heart Throbs. LAST RITES which gave birth to the well-known "Fire Russo" chant. ALL ON ONE SHOW.
I ordered every TNA Monthly PPV that I did not get to attend and this show stopped that trend. Like I said above, take away this main event and this show was just ass. Blindfold Cage Match AND The Electrified Cage Match on one show. The majority of the other matches were nothing special either.
Hard Justice 2007
After a streak of solid shows, this abortion came along and caused some of my friends that went to TNA to never attend TNA again (which is a shame due to the following PPV being so solid). After the opener (which I felt would have been amazing if it was just Daniels & Low Ki/The Guns), this whole show turned into a trainwreck. Rhino/Storm was terrible, VKM/LAX was terrible, Harris/Black Reign was terrible, The Doomsday match was stupid, PACMAN JONES, and the one of the more OBVIOUS swerves ever happening makes this show one of my top 3 worst shows in company history and the worst of the year.
I really hope that this show is not a sign of things to come with Against All Odds this month (a whole tournament being on one show.) In a year of really good PPVs, this PPV was one of the weaker ones of the year. The main event and (then) Terrordome matches were solid, but everything else was short and stupid. Short matches everywhere, the 2nd or 3rd major push of Kazarian that ultimately went nowhere. An overbooked mess.
Final Resolution II: Electric Boogaloo (December 2008)
The opener and main event of this show were good. Rhino/Angle was solid. Everything else reeked of filler. Not necessarily a BAD show such as some of the ones above, but this was essentially a 3 hour Impact.
Against All Odds 2009
Talk about a forgettable/filler PPV. It's not even that there was a bunch of unbearable stuff on this show. It's the fact that there was nothing really good on it at all. Shelley/EY was solid, as was the tag title match, but nothing really memorable at all.
Destination X 2009
I will say that I enjoyed the second half of this show (AJ/Booker, 3D/Beer Money, an overshadowed Ultimate X match, and Sting/Angle). The first half of this show was just downright awful. The opener was iffy, Eric Young getting PINNED by an incredibly green Brutus Magnus after just main eventing the previous Impact after being handpicked by Sting, Kong/SoJo Bolt, Morgan/Abyss in 10,000 tacks, JOE KILLING SCOTT STEINER and the Dating ODB segment. Sheesh. Again, the second half of this show turned it into a decent show in my opinion. Just based on the first half, this show gets a mention.
Victory Road 2009
Not going to get into this. Jenna/Sharmell. Enough said