I've always thought it would be interesting to see somebody with a cult leader/anti-Christ gimmick that goes deeper than just Punk looking like Jesus. It'd be interesting to hear promos about how religion and theists in general are naive and misinformed while at the same time promoting themselves as a savior or higher power. I'm not talking about somebody comparing their character to a deity but someone actually claiming that they're a figure that needs/deserves to be followed or worshipped. Basically, a 21st century version of Charles Manson.
This, plus it would be a new heel stable, named The Elite or something like this, 8-10 people, all dressed in black and white suits, all wearing Anonymous masks (Guy Fawkes masks/Vendetta masks). The leader would be an atheist and say that there is no God and they (The Elite) are controlling everything.
Blond Nazi who dislike nig* em black people and jews
Or what about Bold Zoombie-nazi who's been dead for a while and hasn't cought up on the fact that WW2 is over, and that nazism isn't cool anymore. He's primary goal is to win a (World) Title and influence the people of the world to become Nazis (he doesn't know that nobady watches wrestling). His secondary objective would be to prove that all jews are 1/3 devil, just like Kane. His tertiary goal would be to bully and beat blacks and jews and stuff. He does the Nazi salute to the crowd before and after (if he wins) every match an has an accent.
Would be epic if he bullied Santino for Italy being retards during the war.