Is ICW some indy fed that I'm unaware of?
Serious answer... let's go with HHH. Half the folks dislike him for burying people and giving rambling 20 minute promos where his point can be made in 3 minutes. The other half hail him for his passion, longevity, and contributions to (if I may borrow his line) THIS BUSINESS.
Maybe Cena deserves consideration... but I say that he's not really 'divisive' in the sense that people either love him OR hate him. Cena is loved AND hated simultaneously (ie: John Cena the CHARACTER is hated because he doesn't sell, is booked like a superman, and makes real poor kiddie jokes... John Cena the MAN is respected because of how hard-working he seems for the company, and for making the lives of sick kids better with his tireless Make-A-Wishes)