Re: Is being the biggest draw a good enough reason to be considered the goat?
HBK and Taker, while they are great, are not in the same boat as Hogan/Austin/Rock, this one's not even debatable. They are huge, but Taker lacked mic skills (minus his Deadman gimmick)... it may not be his fault, as his gimmick really doesn't allow for it, but you gotta be a master on the mic here. As for HBK, I really don't see what others see in the guy, yes, he's definitely great, but the male stripper gimmick really held him back, he just lacks the look and the gimmick necessary.
Make no mistake, these dudes are still legends, but they simply aren't even close to the trilogy lol. If I had to pick a 4th, it'd probably be Ric Flair.