2012 : 2 (WM Punk/Jericho, OTL Bryan/Punk)
2011 : 1 (MITB Punk/Cena)
2010 : 1 (WM HBK/Taker)
2009 : 2 (WM HBK/Taker , Bash Rey/Jericho)
2008 : 1(SS Edge/Taker)
2007 : 3(RR Cena/Umaga , WM Taker/Batista, Cena/HBK Raw in London)
2006 : 2 (NWO Angle/Taker)
2005 : 2 (Angle/Michaels , VEN HHH/Batista)
2004 : 1 (WM Triple Threat)
2003 : 5 (RR Angle/Benoit , WM Austin/Rock , WM Y2J/HBK, Taker/Angle SD, Lesnar/Angle SD Ironman) *Crazy how Angle had two MOTYC in three weeks*
2002 : 5 (VEN Triple Threat, SS HBK/HHH , NM Taker/Lesnar, NM Tag Match , SS Chamber)
One thing I noticed while doing this is that I usually see a ***** every 3 years. Here are the matches I have at 5:
Punk/Bryan OTL 2012
Taker/HBK WM25 2009
Taker/Angle NWO 2006
... and guess what the last 5 star match is before that? Foley/HHH RR00... well it would be if not for Rock/Austin WM17.
Nah, but that's still crazy. Because before that it's Austin/Bret WM13... 3 years before Foley/HHH. lol.
Guess I'm looking forward to 2015.