Lets bring it back to '94, shall we?
1994: HBK/Razor Ladder Match: WrestleMania 10 *****
1995: HBK/Razor Ladder Match: SummerSlam'95: ****3/4
1996: HBK/Mankind Mind Games: *****
1997: HBK/Undertaker Hell in a Cell: *****
2000: Triple H vs Cactus Jack Royal Rumble *****
2001: Austin vs The Rock WrestleMania 17 *****
2003 is easily Angle/Benoit to me. Haven't watched any of the matches I'd consider for 1998 and 1999 in along time, so I don't feel comfortable posting what I'd have for them. Perhaps I'll give the matches I consider the best for those years a watch later on this week.
Anyways, this was fun. Fun seeing some of the differences people have for these years. Pretty much all of the matches we list are great matches. It's just a matter of personal preferences from there. Good stuff.
(P.S. 1994-1997 HBK owned.)