Thread Tools

**The Beast Incarnate** · 01-19-2013, 02:26 PM

I love the 06 Rumble, but everything else on the card sucks complete balls and I'm not even going to try and attempt to defend that. JBL JOBS TO THE FUCKING BOOGEYMAN. FUCK. SHITTY DIVAS MATCH. CRUISERWEIGHT OPEN. ANGLE VS HENRY. EDGE VS CENA. AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH.

We get IRONMAN Trips/Rey. That makes the 2006 Royal Rumble worth it DAMNIT.

**Obfuscation** · 01-19-2013, 02:34 PM

Royal Rumble 2006 is so bad that I haven't even bothered trying to watch the Rumble on it. It's got a horrible stigma attached. One match show just like Royal Rumble 2004. Don't know which I hate more. Both SUCK.

Choke2Death · 01-19-2013, 02:38 PM

The 04 Rumble match alone makes the whole PPV worthy of having. Can't say the 06 Rumble is as good to make up for the rest of the terrible card. JBL/Boogeyman was unforgivably bad.

**Obfuscation** · 01-19-2013, 02:39 PM

Mickie vs Ashley was the worst of the worst on that show. Rumble 2004, yikes take your pick at that undercard. I gave a DUD to nearly everything there. Including an Eddie Guerrero match. That's how bad that event is.

**Big Z** · 01-19-2013, 02:41 PM

Yeah 04's RR match makes up for the shitty card no doubt. 06 doesn't have a good undercard at all and the RR match is average.

**The Beast Incarnate** · 01-19-2013, 02:47 PM

Wrestlemania II has been fucking HORRENDOUS so far. Not quite as bad as the first, but I still have to sit through a BOXING match and a ton of other shit. Always liked the Hogan/Bundy cage match for some reason because it's a typical Hogan bread and butter match.

I can't wait to get through this Wrestlemania so I can get to THREE and see if Savage-Steamboat deserves to stay on my FIVE STAR list.

ATF · 01-19-2013, 02:47 PM

RR 04's undercard is still better than 06's IMO (though both are terrible). And at least, 04 does have an excellent LMS Match and one of the greatest RR Matches ever. 06 has a pretty good RR Match, a decent CW Open, and that's it.

**Big Z** · 01-19-2013, 02:50 PM

Yeah 04's undercard is overall better (still sucks balls though, don't care for the LMS match at all). But it really only comes down to the Rumbles and 04's absolutely obliterates 06's. And its still not even the best, nor does it make my top 5!

ATF · 01-19-2013, 02:54 PM

Judgment Day 2006:
MNM/Londrick: ***3/4
Benoit/Finlay: ****1/4
Melina/Jillian: *3/4 (Credit where's due, they actually tried out there)
Helms/Crazy: **1/4
Angle/Henry: **3/4
Booker/Lashley: **3/4
Taker/Khali: DUD
Rey/JBL: ***1/2

JD was quite good. Gotta believe the hype for Benoit/Finlay - a vastly underrated technical masterpiece there. MNM/Londrick is also great, and Rey/JBL is very good. The rest of the midcard is pretty solid, with every match exceeding expectations (except Helms/Crazy, which dissapointed me). Oh and yes, Angle/Henry is MUCH better than their RR DUD.

1 - TIE: Unforgiven
1 - TIE: No Way Out
3 - One Night Stand
4 - WM 22
5 - No Mercy
6 - Armageddon
7 - Judgment Day
8 - Backlash
9 - New Year's Revolution
10 - SummerSlam
11 - Survivor Series
12 - Royal Rumble

Up next: Vengeance. Seems a good watch, I saw RVD/Edge and have that at ****. The rest seems good too (except Umaga/Eugene and the Kane match).

Choke2Death · 01-19-2013, 02:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hailsabin

Mickie vs Ashley was the worst of the worst on that show. Rumble 2004, yikes take your pick at that undercard. I gave a DUD to nearly everything there. Including an Eddie Guerrero match. That's how bad that event is.

I disagree. JBL/Boogeyman was a two minute, almost squash match for Boogeyman. Yeah, he beat a former WWE Champion (for 10 months!) completely clean like it was your normal TV squash. At least with the divas match, Ashley tried to keep up with Mickie even if it was still boring as fuck. The best part of Boogeyman/JBL was Boogeyman's entrance and his pyro looks cool, lol.