TLC IV is good, nothing great though. 8th best TLC match. Ranked them after watching TLC PPV:
13. Edge Vs Kane Vs Rey Mysterio Vs Alberto Del Rio - TLC XI TLC 2010 - **
12. Undertaker Vs Edge - TLC VII One Night Stand 2008 - **1/2
11. DX Vs JeriShow - TLC IX TLC 2009 - **1/2
10. CM Punk Vs Alberto Del Rio Vs The Miz - TLC XII TLC 2011 - **1/2
09. John Cena Vs Edge - TLC VI Unforgiven 2006 - ***
08. Bubba & Spike Vs Kane & Hurricane Vs Chris Jericho & Christian Vs Jeff Hardy & Rob Van Dam - TLC IV Raw 07/10/2002 - ***1/4
07. CM Punk Vs Jeff Hardy - TLC VIII SummerSlam 2009 - ***1/2
06. Jerry Lawler Vs The Miz - TLC X Raw 29/11/2010 - ***1/2
05. The Dudley Boys Vs The Hardy Boys Vs Edge & Christian - TLC II WrestleMania 01/04/2001 - ***3/4
04. Edge Vs Ric Flair - TLC V Raw 16/01/2006 - ***3/4
03. The Shield Vs Team Hell No & Ryback - TLC XIII TLC 2012 - ****
02. The Dudley Boys Vs The Hardy Boys Vs Edge & Christian - TLC I SummerSlam 2000 - ****1/4
01. The Dudley Boys Vs The Hardy Boys Vs Edge & Christian Vs Chris Jericho & Chris Benoit - TLC III Smackdown 24/05/2001 - ****1/2
Good to notice something. Undertaker vs Edge really isn't very good. Taker tried, but it wasn't exactly a fit. vs Hardy on RAW worked, but that's only b/c of the awesome story behind it. Cena vs Edge is pretty meh for me too.
My ratings on a lot of those are pretty high by comparison, haha. I <3 dem LADDERS.
I meant live as in at the arena. Most of the time the live experience bias enhances the match, but that wasn't really the case here. It was entertaining, but very predictable. Plus, did anyone really think Taker would retire?
I may be in the minority but I don't like Undertaker/Edge feud at all. It was just.....lacking. Coming off the epic Undertaker/Batista slugfests it seemed bogged down by the story-line. The WM XIV match was good and that's really the only match I thoroughly enjoyed between them. Their TLC & HIAC matches were just meh to me.
I love their WM, BL and JD matches. TLC is trash and HIAC is good but I find it to be overrated. So overall the matches were mostly really fucking good, but the segments and build up and shit for the most part was just horrible. Definitely prefer the Batista series though.
New Update - November 13th 2015 - Nintendo Direct Thoughts - November 12 2015 !!!