Re: Official DVD/Match/Show Discussion Thread
As a huge fan of both guys, my opinion:
In-ring - Punk.
Mic - Punk.
Face - Edge easily. Punk has never been a great face and Edge could play the role so naturally, just look at his work in Edge and Christian, his time from 2001-2003 and his final few years as a face. Much better. Face punk feels forced.
Heel - Tie. Edge in 2006 was better than anything in Punk's career, but Edge as heel in 2007/2008 I wasn't as big on. Punk's SES work and current work makes this a tie for me imo.
Character - Edge. His Rated R superstar in it's prime in 2006 was better than anything Punk's done, as previously said.
Feuds - Edge. Edge/Cena and Edge/Matt Hardy I enjoyed more than Punk/Jeff Hardy or Punk/Cena.
Look - Edge without question.
Last edited by Nostalgia; 12-08-2012 at 07:14 PM.